A geographer finds that areas of Bolivia with the highest proportion of indigenous community land titles (TCO) show lower rates of agricultural land conversion compared to areas with private or no formal tenure. Which conclusion do these data BEST support?
- APrivate land tenure encourages conservation, because individual owners invest in long-term productivity and avoid degrading property they hold
- BIndigenous communities have little incentive to protect land they own collectively, since shared ownership weakens each member's responsibility for it
- CAny form of formal land title reduces agricultural conversion, because legal ownership by itself discourages landholders from clearing forest
- DGovernment-managed reserves prevent deforestation more effectively than community-owned territories, because centralized state enforcement is stronger than local control
- ERecognizing indigenous land titles is an effective conservation strategy, because communities gain both the authority and the incentive to prevent conversionCorrect
Why E is right
Research across tropical forest regions consistently shows that formally recognized indigenous territories and community-managed lands have lower deforestation rates than unprotected or privately owned areas. Communities have deep place-based relationships with their territories and, with legal authority to exclude outsiders, can effectively prevent agricultural encroachment and maintain forest cover.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Reversed: the data show higher land conversion in private-tenure areas than in indigenous community titles, so private tenure is associated with less, not more, conservation.
- B
- Contradicted by the data: community-titled areas show lower conversion, indicating communities actively protect their land; a lack of incentive would predict higher conversion.
- C
- Overgeneralization: private tenure is also a formal title, yet private-tenure areas show higher conversion than indigenous community titles, so the effect is tied to indigenous community titling, not to formal ownership as such.
- D
- Unsupported: the comparison is between indigenous community titles and private or untitled land; government reserves are not part of the data, so no claim about their relative effectiveness follows.