A geographer comparing the economic development trajectories of South Korea and Ghana — both low-income countries in the 1960s — argues that neither geography, climate, nor natural resources adequately explains why South Korea became a high-income country while Ghana did not. This argument challenges which geographic perspective?
- ASequent occupance, because it ignores the historical layers of both countries' development
- BVernacular regionalism, because it challenges popular perceptions of 'developed' and 'developing' regions
- CEnvironmental determinism, because it argues physical geography does not determine development outcomesCorrect
- DPossibilism, because it denies environmental constraints matter
- ECultural landscape theory, because it says human activity reshapes the physical environment
Why C is right
By arguing that geography, climate, and natural resources do not explain South Korea's development success relative to Ghana, the geographer is directly challenging environmental determinism — the view that physical environmental factors determine economic development trajectories. The comparison is a classic empirical argument against geographic determinism.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- The argument is about what explains divergent development paths, not about ignoring historical layers. Sequent occupance is a landscape analysis concept, not a development explanation.
- B
- The argument challenges deterministic explanations for development, not popular perceptions. Vernacular regionalism is not the target of the critique.
- D
- Possibilism acknowledges environmental constraints while emphasizing human agency. The geographer's argument is consistent with possibilism, not a challenge to it. The argument challenges determinism, not possibilism.
- E
- The cultural landscape perspective (Sauer) stresses human agency in shaping the land. Like possibilism, it fits the geographer's claim that people, not the physical environment, drive outcomes, so the argument does not challenge it. Students who see 'human vs. environment' may pick any human-environment term, but only environmental determinism claims that physical geography decides development.