Read the following practice passage.
In the 1970s, farmers in a semi-arid river district began planting short-stemmed wheat and rice that produced far larger harvests when given fertilizer and steady water. Owners of large holdings used bank loans to sink tube wells and buy diesel pumps, and their output soon doubled. Smallholders, lacking collateral, bought water from their neighbors at high prices; many fell into debt and eventually sold or leased their plots to the larger farms. By the 1990s, district grain output was triple its earlier level, yet wells that once struck water at 10 meters had to be drilled past 40, and some of the shallowest had gone dry.
The developments described in the passage most directly illustrate which criticism of this agricultural transformation?
- AReplacing many local crop varieties with a few uniform strains reduced the genetic diversity of the region's crops
- BHeavy pesticide applications polluted nearby rivers and harmed fish and the people who drank the water
- CMachinery on large farms displaced hired laborers, pushing many rural workers to migrate to cities
- DUnequal access to credit and irrigation let larger farmers gain the most, while heavy pumping drew down the groundwater that sustained higher yieldsCorrect
- EReliance on seeds and chemicals sold by foreign firms left farmers dependent on prices set outside the country
Why D is right
The passage describes large landowners using bank loans to buy tube wells and pumps while smallholders without collateral paid high prices for water, fell into debt, and lost their plots to larger farms, which shows that the gains went unevenly to wealthier farmers. It also reports that the water table fell from 10 meters to past 40 and that shallow wells went dry, which shows that the irrigation behind the higher yields was depleting groundwater. Both parts of choice D come straight from the passage. The other choices are real criticisms of Green Revolution agriculture, but the passage gives no evidence for them.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Loss of crop genetic diversity is a real criticism of the Green Revolution, but the passage never says local varieties were abandoned or that diversity declined. It mentions only the new wheat and rice.
- B
- Chemical runoff is a documented criticism, but the passage mentions fertilizer only as an input and says nothing about pesticides, polluted rivers, or health effects.
- C
- Labor displacement by mechanization is a real criticism, but the pumps in the passage are for irrigation, not harvesting, and the passage never mentions hired laborers or migration to cities.
- E
- Dependence on foreign agribusiness is a real criticism, but the passage says the loans came from banks and the water from neighbors. It never mentions foreign firms or outside prices.