The table shows hypothetical data on settlements in five regions, each located on a similar flat, uniform plain.
| Region | Small towns (number) | Small towns: avg. spacing (km) | Large cities (number) | Large cities: avg. spacing (km) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Region 1 | 48 | 12 | 3 | 46 |
| Region 2 | 20 | 30 | 18 | 14 |
| Region 3 | 40 | 15 | 12 | 15 |
| Region 4 | 14 | 40 | 9 | 22 |
| Region 5 | 40 | 14 | 2 | 13 |
Which region's settlement pattern best matches the hierarchy predicted by Christaller's central place theory?
- ARegion 2, with 20 small towns and 18 large cities
- BRegion 1, which has 48 small towns and 3 large citiesCorrect
- CRegion 3, with 40 small towns and 12 large cities
- DRegion 4, with 14 small towns and 9 large cities
- ERegion 5, with 40 small towns and 2 large cities
Why B is right
Central place theory predicts that large cities, which offer higher-order goods with large thresholds and ranges, will be fewer in number AND spaced farther apart than small towns. Region 1 is the only region where both conditions hold in the table: it has 3 large cities and 48 small towns, and its large cities average 46 km apart compared with 12 km for its small towns. Every other region has fewer large cities than small towns, but in each of them the large cities are spaced the same distance as the small towns or closer together. That means the spacing columns, not the counts, decide the answer.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Region 2 has slightly fewer large cities than small towns, but its large cities are much closer together (14 km) than its small towns (30 km), the reverse of the predicted spacing.
- C
- Region 3 has fewer large cities than small towns, but both tiers are spaced the same distance apart (15 km). The theory predicts that higher-order centers are spaced more widely.
- D
- Region 4 has fewer large cities than small towns, but its large cities (22 km) are closer together than its small towns (40 km). This is a misreading that checks only the counts.
- E
- Region 5 has the biggest town-to-city ratio, which tempts a student who reads only the counts. However, its 2 large cities are spaced about the same distance apart as its small towns (13 km vs. 14 km), so there are no wide market areas for the large cities.