The following is a practice passage describing two groups of refugees displaced by the same civil conflict.
Group 1 has lived for nearly two decades in a camp complex a short drive from the border of the country it fled. Residents need a permit to leave the camp, formal jobs are closed to them, and most families rely on monthly food rations. Many young adults have never seen their parents' hometowns. Group 2 was admitted to a distant midwestern city. Its members hold work authorization, and many now drive taxis or run small groceries, yet parents describe struggling with long winters, an unfamiliar language, and children who prefer English at home.
Which of the following conclusions about the two groups is best supported by the passage?
- AGroup 2 lacks the legal right to work, so its members depend more heavily on aid than the members of Group 1 do
- BGroup 1 has gained steady employment through cross-border trade made possible by the camp's nearness to the homeland
- CBecause both groups fled the same conflict, their members report largely the same everyday constraints and challenges
- DGroup 2 faces tighter limits on movement than Group 1, since its members need permits to leave their assigned district
- EGroup 1 faces protracted encampment marked by restricted mobility and aid dependence, while Group 2 faces cultural adaptation in a very different settingCorrect
Why E is right
The passage shows that the geographic context of displacement shapes refugee experience. Group 1 lives in a protracted refugee situation: a long-term camp near the border, with permits needed to leave, no formal jobs, and dependence on rations. Group 2 has been resettled far away. Its members can work and move freely, but the passage describes adjusting to a new climate, a new language, and children assimilating at home. Choice E is the only conclusion that matches the evidence for both groups.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage says Group 2 holds work authorization and runs businesses, while Group 1 relies on food rations; this reverses the two groups.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage states that formal jobs are closed to Group 1 and that families rely on rations; nearness to the border has not produced steady employment.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage describes very different daily realities: permits and rations for Group 1, versus jobs, climate, and language adjustment for Group 2.
- D
- Incorrect because the permit requirement in the passage applies to Group 1's camp, not to Group 2; this confuses encampment with resettlement.