Data from a long-term ecological study show that a temperate lake's phytoplankton productivity decreased by 35% over 15 years, while dissolved phosphorus concentrations remained stable. Simultaneously, invasive zebra mussels increased in population density by 500%. Which interpretation is best supported by these data?
- AClimate change lowered summer water temperatures, slowing phytoplankton growth and metabolism
- BZebra mussels removed phytoplankton through filter feeding, reducing standing biomassCorrect
- CAgricultural runoff introduced herbicides that selectively killed phytoplankton in the lake
- DIncreased UV radiation from ozone depletion damaged phytoplankton cells
Why B is right
The data show a strong inverse correlation between zebra mussel population growth (500% increase) and phytoplankton productivity decline (35% decrease), while nutrients remained stable. Zebra mussels are prolific filter feeders that can filter large volumes of water, removing phytoplankton and reducing standing biomass. The stable phosphorus levels rule out nutrient limitation as the cause.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. While temperature affects metabolism, the question provides no temperature data. The strong correlation with zebra mussel invasion provides a more direct and supported explanation.
- C
- Incorrect. If herbicides were the cause, we would expect to see changes in water chemistry beyond stable phosphorus. Additionally, the strong temporal correlation with zebra mussel invasion is a more parsimonious explanation.
- D
- Incorrect. UV radiation increases from ozone depletion are primarily a concern at high latitudes and would affect a broader range of aquatic organisms, not just phytoplankton. The zebra mussel correlation is a stronger explanation.