Skip to content
AP Environmental Science · Living World: Ecosystems and Biodiversity

Keystone species

Keystone species appears in 22 reviewed AP Environmental Science questions and sits in Living World: Ecosystems and Biodiversity. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Keystone species is tested

Example 1Medium
A researcher removes all predators from a small island ecosystem. Over the next 10 years, the herbivore population grows, plant diversity declines, and several plant species go locally extinct. This experiment demonstrates which ecological concept?
  1. ATrophic cascade, where removing a top predator sets off effects down the food chainCorrect
  2. BIsland biogeography, where species richness is limited by the area and isolation of the island
  3. CEcological succession, where the plant community naturally progresses toward a climax state
  4. DCompetitive exclusion, where herbivores outcompete plants for soil nutrients

Why A is right

A trophic cascade occurs when changes at the top of a food web cascade downward, affecting multiple lower trophic levels. Removing predators releases herbivores from predation pressure, causing herbivore population explosion, which then over-grazes plants and reduces plant diversity. This is a top-down trophic cascade.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Island biogeography theory predicts species richness based on island size and distance from the mainland; while the experiment occurs on an island, the mechanism driving the change is predator removal, not island characteristics.
C
Ecological succession is directional change in community composition over time in response to disturbance; this scenario is driven by predator removal, not natural succession processes.
D
Competitive exclusion refers to competition between similar species for the same resources; this scenario involves predator-prey relationships, not competition between plants and herbivores for nutrients.
Example 2Medium
The concept of 'trophic cascade' refers to which ecological phenomenon?
  1. AThe gradual increase in toxin concentration as pollutants move up the food chain.
  2. BThe sequential transfer of energy from producers to top consumers, losing 90% at each step.
  3. CThe indirect effects on lower trophic levels caused by changes in a top predator's population.Correct
  4. DThe cascading collapse of multiple food chains following the extinction of a keystone producer.

Why C is right

A trophic cascade occurs when a change in a top predator population indirectly affects organisms at lower trophic levels. The classic example: when wolves were eliminated from Yellowstone, elk populations increased, which overgrazing riparian vegetation (willows, aspens), causing stream bank erosion and changes in stream morphology. When wolves were reintroduced, elk behavior changed, vegetation recovered, and stream conditions improved. This indirect effect of a predator on plants via herbivore regulation is a trophic cascade.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
The increase in toxin concentration at higher trophic levels describes biomagnification, not trophic cascades; biomagnification and trophic cascades are different ecological concepts, though both involve food web dynamics.
B
The 90% energy loss between trophic levels describes the trophic energy transfer rule (10% efficiency rule), not a trophic cascade; trophic cascades are about indirect ecological effects, not energy transfer efficiency.
D
Loss of a keystone producer might cause a bottom-up cascade, but the term 'trophic cascade' most commonly refers to top-down indirect effects initiated by changes in predator populations, not producer collapses.
Example 3Easier
A keystone species is defined as a species that has a disproportionately large effect on its ecosystem relative to its abundance. Which of the following best illustrates the concept of a keystone species?
  1. AA decomposer fungus that breaks down leaf litter on a forest floor
  2. BAn invasive plant that rapidly colonizes disturbed habitats and outcompetes native vegetation
  3. CA dominant tree species that comprises 80% of a forest canopy and provides habitat for many organisms
  4. DA predatory sea star that prevents a single mussel species from monopolizing rocky intertidal zones, maintaining high species diversityCorrect

Why D is right

The classic example of a keystone species is the sea star Pisaster ochraceus studied by Robert Paine. Despite being relatively uncommon, its predation on competitively dominant mussels prevents the mussels from monopolizing space on rocky intertidal surfaces, allowing many other species to coexist. Removing this single predator causes a dramatic decline in species diversity.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because while decomposer fungi play important roles in nutrient cycling, a common decomposer functioning as expected does not demonstrate the disproportionate community-level effects that define a keystone species.
B
Incorrect because an invasive species that outcompetes natives reduces biodiversity rather than maintaining it; while invasives can have large effects, they are not keystone species in the ecological definition.
C
Incorrect because a species that dominates by sheer abundance is a dominant species, not a keystone species. Keystone species have effects disproportionate to their low abundance, while dominant species influence ecosystems through their numerical or biomass dominance.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Living World: Ecosystems and Biodiversity.