A marine ecologist removes all sea otters from a kelp forest ecosystem as part of a long-term study. Over the following years, the kelp forest disappears and is replaced by barren sea urchin grounds. Which of the following best explains this outcome?
- AThe removal of sea otters reduced water turbidity, allowing too much sunlight to reach the kelp and causing photodamage
- BSea otters were competing with kelp for nutrients, and their removal allowed nutrient levels to drop below what kelp needed to survive
- CSea otters physically anchored kelp to the ocean floor, and without them the kelp was swept away by currents
- DWithout sea otter predation, sea urchin populations exploded and overgrazed the kelp, transforming the ecosystem into an urchin barrenCorrect
Why D is right
Sea otters are a keystone predator in kelp forest ecosystems. They control sea urchin populations through predation. When otters are removed, sea urchin populations grow unchecked and overgraze kelp holdfasts and fronds, destroying the kelp forest and creating vast urchin barrens devoid of complex habitat structure. This is a classic example of a trophic cascade.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because sea otters do not significantly affect water turbidity, and kelp thrives in clear, sunlit water; the mechanism of kelp loss following otter removal is urchin herbivory, not photodamage.
- B
- Incorrect because sea otters are animals that do not compete with kelp for nutrients; the ecosystem change is driven by the release of sea urchin populations from predation, not by nutrient competition.
- C
- Incorrect because sea otters do not physically anchor kelp; kelp attaches to rocky substrates via holdfasts. The loss of kelp is caused by urchin overgrazing, not physical detachment.