The intermediate disturbance hypothesis predicts that species diversity is highest at moderate levels of disturbance. Which explanation best supports this prediction?
- AModerate disturbance prevents competitive exclusion by dominants yet still lets sensitive species persistCorrect
- BLow disturbance allows maximum niche differentiation because all habitats remain intact
- CHigh disturbance promotes the immigration of invasive species, which increases the overall species richness of the community
- DModerate disturbance eliminates all pioneer species, allowing climax species to dominate
Why A is right
The intermediate disturbance hypothesis (Connell, 1978) proposes that moderate disturbance maintains diversity by creating a mosaic of successional stages. Competitive dominants cannot exclude other species because periodic disturbance resets portions of the community, while disturbance is not so frequent or severe that only rapid colonizers (pioneer species) can survive. This balance maximizes coexistence.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect. Low disturbance actually allows competitive exclusion to proceed to completion, reducing diversity as dominant species outcompete others. Intact habitats do not automatically maximize diversity.
- C
- Incorrect. High disturbance typically reduces species diversity by allowing only disturbance-tolerant species to persist. Invasive species from high disturbance often reduce native species richness.
- D
- Incorrect. Moderate disturbance does not eliminate pioneer species; it maintains a mixture of both pioneer and later-successional species. Elimination of pioneers would actually reduce diversity.