An ecologist hypothesizes that both top-down and bottom-up forces simultaneously regulate a stream ecosystem. Which experimental finding would best support this hypothesis?
- ARemoving predators increases herbivore populations, and adding nutrients increases primary producer biomass, with both effects propagating through the food webCorrect
- BOnly predator removal affects population sizes; nutrient addition has no measurable effect
- CNeither predator removal nor nutrient addition has any effect on any trophic level
- DOnly nutrient addition increases primary producer and herbivore populations; removing predators has no measurable effect on herbivore or producer abundance at any level
Why A is right
If both top-down and bottom-up forces operate simultaneously, then manipulating either end of the food web should produce measurable effects. Removing predators (testing top-down control) should increase herbivore populations, and adding nutrients (testing bottom-up control) should increase primary producer biomass. If both manipulations produce effects that cascade through the food web, it supports the hypothesis of dual regulation.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because if only predator removal has an effect, this would support exclusively top-down control, not simultaneous top-down and bottom-up regulation.
- C
- Incorrect because if neither manipulation has any effect, it would suggest that neither top-down nor bottom-up forces regulate this ecosystem, contradicting the hypothesis entirely.
- D
- Incorrect because if only nutrient addition has an effect (even one that raises producer and herbivore populations), this would support exclusively bottom-up control, not simultaneous regulation by both forces.