The energy return on investment (EROI) measures the ratio of energy produced to energy consumed in producing that energy. Which energy source typically has the highest EROI?
- ATar sands oil (EROI ~5:1)
- BHydroelectric power from a large dam (EROI ~40:1)Correct
- CCorn ethanol (EROI ~1.3:1)
- DConventional oil from a large reservoir (EROI ~20:1)
Why B is right
Hydroelectric power typically has the highest EROI among major energy sources, often exceeding 40:1. Once a dam is constructed, the energy input required to maintain and operate it is minimal compared to the electricity produced over its 50-100+ year lifespan. Gravity and the water cycle provide continuous free energy input.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. Tar sands oil has a relatively low EROI (~5:1) because extraction requires enormous energy inputs for mining, heating, and processing the bitumen-laden sands.
- C
- Incorrect. Corn ethanol has one of the lowest EROIs of any commercial energy source (~1.3:1), meaning it barely produces more energy than is consumed in growing corn, processing, and distillation.
- D
- Incorrect. While conventional oil has a good EROI (~20:1), it is still lower than hydroelectric power. Conventional oil EROI has also declined over time as easily accessible reserves are depleted.