Skip to content
AP Environmental Science · Energy Resources and Consumption

Energy comparison

Energy comparison appears in 4 reviewed AP Environmental Science questions and sits in Energy Resources and Consumption. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Energy comparison is tested

Example 1Medium
Which of the following accurately compares the environmental impacts of nuclear energy and coal energy?
  1. ACoal produces less CO₂ per unit of electricity than nuclear
  2. BNuclear emits little air pollution or CO₂ in operation but yields long-lived radioactive wasteCorrect
  3. CNuclear produces more air pollution than coal during operation but generates less solid waste overall
  4. DBoth nuclear and coal plants produce identical types and quantities of waste, so their disposal challenges are the same

Why B is right

Nuclear fission produces no direct air pollution, SO₂, NOₓ, or CO₂ during electricity generation. However, it produces radioactive waste that remains hazardous for thousands of years, requiring secure long-term storage. Coal produces large quantities of air pollutants and CO₂ but no radioactive waste.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because coal produces far more CO₂ per unit of electricity than nuclear; nuclear lifecycle emissions are comparable to wind and solar.
C
Incorrect because nuclear power produces virtually no air pollution during operation; coal produces significant quantities of SO₂, NOₓ, CO₂, and particulates.
D
Incorrect because nuclear produces small volumes of radioactive waste while coal produces large volumes of ash, slag, and atmospheric pollutants—very different waste profiles, so their disposal challenges differ.
Example 2Medium
The energy return on investment (EROI) measures the ratio of energy produced to energy consumed in producing that energy. Which energy source typically has the highest EROI?
  1. ATar sands oil (EROI ~5:1)
  2. BHydroelectric power from a large dam (EROI ~40:1)Correct
  3. CCorn ethanol (EROI ~1.3:1)
  4. DConventional oil from a large reservoir (EROI ~20:1)

Why B is right

Hydroelectric power typically has the highest EROI among major energy sources, often exceeding 40:1. Once a dam is constructed, the energy input required to maintain and operate it is minimal compared to the electricity produced over its 50-100+ year lifespan. Gravity and the water cycle provide continuous free energy input.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect. Tar sands oil has a relatively low EROI (~5:1) because extraction requires enormous energy inputs for mining, heating, and processing the bitumen-laden sands.
C
Incorrect. Corn ethanol has one of the lowest EROIs of any commercial energy source (~1.3:1), meaning it barely produces more energy than is consumed in growing corn, processing, and distillation.
D
Incorrect. While conventional oil has a good EROI (~20:1), it is still lower than hydroelectric power. Conventional oil EROI has also declined over time as easily accessible reserves are depleted.
Example 3Medium
Which environmental impact is unique to nuclear power generation and not shared with fossil fuel combustion?
  1. AGeneration of long-lived radioactive waste requiring secure storage for thousands of yearsCorrect
  2. BThermal pollution of water bodies used for cooling
  3. CContribution to global warming through direct greenhouse gas emissions during electricity generation
  4. DAir pollution from smokestack emissions during normal operation

Why A is right

Nuclear power generates high-level radioactive waste (spent fuel rods) that remains hazardous for thousands to hundreds of thousands of years and requires secure geological storage. This is unique to nuclear power. No other commercial energy source produces waste that remains dangerous for such extended periods and requires such specialized containment.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect. Thermal pollution from cooling water discharge is shared by both nuclear and fossil fuel power plants. Both use steam turbines that require cooling water, which is returned to water bodies at elevated temperatures.
C
Incorrect. Nuclear power produces virtually no direct greenhouse gas emissions during electricity generation. CO2 emissions are associated with fuel cycle activities (mining, enrichment, construction) but are far lower per kWh than fossil fuels.
D
Incorrect. Nuclear power plants do not produce smokestack air emissions during normal operation. This is an impact of fossil fuel combustion, not nuclear power. Nuclear plants emit only water vapor from cooling towers.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Energy Resources and Consumption.