The Watch-Repair Shop
The following passage is from a short story. A woman returns to the shop her father ran for decades, a few months after his death.
The bell above the door still rang when Ruth pushed it open, though the sign in the window had said CLOSED since the middle of March. Inside, the shop smelled the way it always had, of oil and brass and the peppermints her father kept in a jar beside the register for children who would not stop touching things that did not belong to them.
She had come to empty it. The buyer, a pleasant young man who called her ma'am in every sentence, wanted the space cleared by Friday so that he could open a phone store.
Forty-one clocks hung on the back wall, and every one of them had stopped at a different time, which she had expected and had prepared herself to see. What she had not expected was the ledger, lying open on the workbench and filled in her father's small square handwriting, as careful on the last page as on the first. Each line recorded a customer's name, the make of the watch, what was wrong with it, and the price of the repair. Most of the entries ended the same way, with two words in the final column: no charge. The column of free repairs ran down the page and onto the next, and onto the one after that, as though he had decided years ago that his time was the one thing in the shop he would not sell.
He had charged her, once. She was nineteen and had dropped the watch he gave her for graduation, and he had fixed it in an evening and then handed her a slip of paper with a figure written on it. 'So you learn what things cost,' he said. She paid it out of her waitressing tips, counting the bills onto the counter one at a time, and she did not speak to him for most of that summer.
She turned the pages now. No charge. No charge. Her own name did not appear anywhere.
On the bench lay his loupe, the small black eyepiece he had worn so often that she had believed, as a girl, it was simply part of his face. She picked it up and held it to her eye. The world shrank to a bright circle in which a screw no larger than a grain of sand, a scratch in the varnished wood, and the edge of her own thumb, enormous and ridged like a map, all seemed equally important.
Up close, she thought, everything needed fixing.
She did not take the clocks. She took the ledger, the loupe, and the jar of peppermints, and she left the door unlocked behind her, because the bell was the only thing in the shop that still worked and she could not bring herself to silence it.
- (Task)Read the passage carefully. Then, in a well-organized essay, analyze how the author uses literary elements and techniques to portray Ruth's complicated feelings about her father. In your essay, make a defensible claim about the passage, support it with specific evidence from the text, and explain how that evidence develops your claim. Write clearly enough that a reader can follow your argument.