Skip to content

Free-response practice

The Literary Argument Essay

6 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

The literary argument essay is Question 3 of Section II on the AP English Literature exam. Unlike the poetry and prose essays, it gives you no passage. Instead, the prompt describes a literary idea, such as a character who keeps a secret or a family torn by an old debt. You then choose a novel, play, or other work of fiction that you know well and argue how that idea shapes the meaning of the work as a whole.

On this page · 6 sections

The prompt usually ends with a list of suggested titles, and the length of that list varies from year to year. You are free to pick any work of comparable literary merit. Choose a book you studied closely in class, not one you skimmed or only saw as a film. All your evidence comes from memory, so you need names, scenes, and a few short phrases you can recall without the text in front of you. Accurate paraphrase counts as evidence, and you do not need exact quotations.

Section II gives you 2 hours for three essays: poetry analysis, prose fiction analysis, and this literary argument. There is no separate reading period, and the section clock is shared, so plan on about 40 minutes per essay. Section II is worth 55% of your exam score, and each essay is scored out of 6 points, so this one essay carries roughly 18% of your score.

Every essay is scored on the same three-row analytic rubric. Row A is the thesis (0 or 1 point). Row B is evidence and commentary (0 to 4 points). Row C is sophistication (0 or 1 point). Readers are trained high school and college English teachers. They read the whole essay, then decide each row on what you did well, not on a list of errors. Grammar and spelling only cost you when they make your meaning hard to follow.

The skill being tested is interpretation. A strong response does not prove that the prompt's idea appears in the book. It explains what the idea reveals about the whole work, which means a claim about theme, character, or the author's view of the world.

The rubric, in plain terms

6 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Thesis (Row A)1 pt

State a defensible interpretation of your chosen work that answers the prompt. The claim must say what the prompt's idea reveals about the work as a whole, not just that the idea appears in it. It can be one sentence or a few sentences together, anywhere in the essay. You get 0 if you only restate the prompt, name the work and the topic with no claim, or give a claim that has nothing to do with the prompt.

Evidence and Commentary (Row B)4 pts

This row is a ladder. 1 point: you mostly retell the plot, with little or no explanation of how it supports a claim. 2 points: you cite specific, relevant moments, but the commentary is thin or repeats the same point, so the link to your argument is asserted more than explained. 3 points: you use specific evidence and explain how some of it builds a line of reasoning, though gaps remain or some scenes go unexplained. 4 points: specific evidence appears throughout, and you consistently explain how each piece supports one clear line of reasoning that leads back to your interpretation.

Sophistication (Row C)1 pt

Show complex thinking about the work, and sustain it across the essay. Ways to earn it: weigh a tension or contradiction in the work instead of flattening it, consider another reasonable reading and show why yours holds, place the work in a wider literary or historical context that sharpens your claim, or write with a precise and vivid style that drives the argument. One clever sentence, a quote dropped into the conclusion, or big vocabulary does not earn it. This point almost always goes to essays already strong in Row B.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

The Routine That Outlives Its Reason

In many works of literature, a character holds on to a daily routine or a fixed habit long after the circumstances that gave it meaning have changed. The routine may shelter the character from pain, trap the character in the past, or do both at once.

Either from your own reading or from the list below, choose a work of fiction in which a character clings to a routine or habit. Then, in a well-written essay, analyze how the character's attachment to that routine contributes to an interpretation of the work as a whole.

In your response you should do the following: - Respond to the prompt with a thesis that presents a defensible interpretation. - Provide evidence to support your line of reasoning. - Explain how the evidence supports your line of reasoning. - Use appropriate grammar and punctuation in communicating your argument.

Suggested works: A Doll's House; The Old Man and the Sea; Death of a Salesman; Great Expectations; Mrs. Dalloway; Never Let Me Go; One Hundred Years of Solitude; Pride and Prejudice; The Remains of the Day; The Glass Menagerie; Things Fall Apart; Their Eyes Were Watching God; Wuthering Heights; Ethan Frome; Sula.

  1. (A)Choose a work of fiction in which a character clings to a routine or habit. In a well-written essay, analyze how the character's attachment to that routine contributes to an interpretation of the work as a whole.
Prompt 2

The Disputed Inheritance

An object handed down within a family can hold more meaning than its owners agree on. One relative sees a memory that must be protected. Another sees something to use, to sell, or to display. The argument over the object is rarely only about the object.

Either from your own reading or from the list below, choose a work of fiction in which characters disagree about what an inherited object, house, or piece of land means. Then, in a well-written essay, analyze how that disagreement contributes to an interpretation of the work as a whole.

In your response you should do the following: - Respond to the prompt with a thesis that presents a defensible interpretation. - Provide evidence to support your line of reasoning. - Explain how the evidence supports your line of reasoning. - Use appropriate grammar and punctuation in communicating your argument.

Suggested works: A Raisin in the Sun; Everyday Use; Howards End; King Lear; The Cherry Orchard; The Joy Luck Club; Middlemarch; The Mill on the Floss; The Piano Lesson; Pride and Prejudice; Song of Solomon; The House of the Spirits; Wuthering Heights; Fences; The God of Small Things.

  1. (A)Choose a work of fiction in which characters disagree about what an inherited object, house, or piece of land means. In a well-written essay, analyze how that disagreement contributes to an interpretation of the work as a whole.

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

The Routine That Outlives Its Reason · high-scoring response6/6

In Kazuo Ishiguro's The Remains of the Day, Stevens, the butler of Darlington Hall, clings to the routine of perfect service because it lets him avoid judging what his life has meant. The routine protects him from grief and guilt. But by the end of the novel it is clear that this protection is exactly what cost him his father, the woman he loved, and his own moral voice. Ishiguro uses Stevens's habit to argue that a person can do his job flawlessly and still waste his life.

The clearest example is the 1923 conference that Lord Darlington hosts. Stevens's father, an under-butler, collapses and lies dying upstairs while Stevens serves port to diplomats. Stevens keeps moving between the sickroom and the guests, and when his father dies he does not go up right away because the guests still need him. Years later he even remembers that night as a kind of triumph. The routine is doing exactly what Stevens wants: it gives him a task so he does not have to feel anything. But Ishiguro makes the reader see what Stevens does not. On the same night, a French delegate asks Stevens to help with his sore, blistered feet, so Stevens is literally tending a stranger's feet while his father dies. The novel makes the routine look absurd at the very moment Stevens is proudest of it.

The same pattern shapes his relationship with Miss Kenton, the housekeeper. When she brings flowers to his pantry, he turns them down. When she catches him reading a sentimental love story, he claims he reads it to improve his vocabulary. Every time she gets close, he retreats into his professional manner. On the night she tells him she has accepted a marriage proposal, he hears her crying behind her door, stands in the corridor, and then goes back downstairs because important visitors are in the house. Because he never steps out of his role, the moment passes. Twenty years later he drives across England, telling himself it is a staffing matter, hoping she will come back to Darlington Hall. She will not.

The routine also hides Stevens from moral responsibility. In the 1930s Lord Darlington orders him to dismiss two Jewish maids, and Stevens does it, telling himself that a good butler does not question his employer. Only later does he claim he privately disagreed. His idea of dignity, never letting a personal feeling show, sounds like a virtue. In this scene it means he helped do something wrong while insisting it was not his business. The routine turns obedience into a kind of moral sleep.

What makes the novel more than a warning is that Ishiguro does not simply mock Stevens. His professionalism is real skill, and the ending does not have him throw it away. On the pier at Weymouth he finally admits to a stranger that he gave everything to Lord Darlington and cannot even say he made his own mistakes, and he cries. Yet a moment later he decides to practice bantering so he can better please his new American employer, Mr. Farraday. He answers the collapse of one routine by building another. The ending is sad and oddly hopeful at once. Stevens has seen the truth for a moment, but he still needs a duty to hold on to, because duty is the only way he knows how to live.

Through Stevens's routine, Ishiguro shows that a habit can be a hiding place that feels like honor. The remains of the day are what is left after years of perfect performance, and the novel asks whether a life of service means anything if the servant never let himself choose what he served.

How it scored

1/1A — The opening paragraph makes a defensible interpretation, not a topic statement: Stevens's routine shields him from feeling and judgment, and that shield is what costs him his father, Miss Kenton, and his moral voice. It answers the prompt's 'work as a whole' by naming what Ishiguro argues about a life of perfect service.
4/4B — Every body paragraph pairs a specific scene with an explanation of how it advances the thesis: the 1923 conference and the blistered feet, the flowers and the love story, the corridor outside Miss Kenton's door, the dismissed maids. Each piece of evidence is tied back to the same idea, that the routine lets Stevens avoid feeling or judging. The reasoning builds instead of repeating.
1/1C — The essay refuses an easy reading. It grants that Stevens's skill is real, then reads the bantering decision on the Weymouth pier as both sad and hopeful, a new routine replacing the old. Holding that tension through the final two paragraphs, and turning the title into a question about chosen service, is sustained complex thinking.
The Routine That Outlives Its Reason · mid-scoring response3/6

In the play Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, Willy Loman holds onto his routine as a salesman even when it is not working anymore. This shows that he cannot let go of the past and it leads to his downfall.

Willy is 63 years old and has been a traveling salesman his whole life. At the beginning of the play he comes home early from his trip because he kept drifting off the road. His wife Linda tells him to ask his boss for a job in New York so he doesn't have to travel. This shows that his routine is wearing him out. He keeps driving to New England anyway because being a salesman is his whole identity. He believes being well liked is the most important thing and that is how he has always done his job.

Another example is when Willy goes to his boss Howard to ask for a job in New York. Howard is playing with his new wire recorder and does not really listen. Willy tells him about Dave Singleman, an old salesman who could make a living from his hotel room and had hundreds of salesmen at his funeral. Howard fires him instead. This shows that the world has changed but Willy has not. The routine he believed in does not exist anymore.

Willy also plants seeds in the backyard at night with a flashlight. He is doing this as a planned ritual to say goodbye to his family, because he knows he is going to die and wants to leave something behind. This shows he is desperate and the seeds symbolize his hope.

At the end of the play Willy kills himself in his car so his family can get the insurance money. At the funeral almost nobody comes except his family, Charley and Bernard, which is the opposite of Dave Singleman. Linda says she made the last payment on the house today and now there will be nobody home. This is very sad because Willy worked his whole life for the house and now he is not there to live in it.

Overall, Willy's routine as a salesman shows he cannot let go of the past and this is what destroys him. Miller is showing that the American Dream is not real for people like Willy.

How it scored

1/1A — The claim that Willy cannot let go of the past and that his routine leads to his downfall is defensible and answers the prompt. It is simple and says little about what Miller means by it, but it is a real interpretation, so it earns the point.
2/4B — The evidence is specific and accurate: Willy drifting off the road, Howard's wire recorder, Dave Singleman, the seeds, Linda's last house payment. The commentary rarely goes past 'this shows,' so the link between each scene and the thesis is stated, not explained. The seeds paragraph points to a real link between the planting and Willy's plan to leave his family something, since he plants while talking through the insurance scheme with Ben. But it never ties the act back to the routine of salesmanship that the thesis is about, and 'this shows he is desperate' is assertion, not explanation. The funeral paragraph is mostly retelling.
0/1C — The essay never complicates its reading. The final line about the American Dream is a broad claim added at the end with no development, and readers do not award sophistication for a big idea named once in the conclusion.
The Disputed Inheritance · high-scoring response5/6

In August Wilson's The Piano Lesson, Berniece and her brother Boy Willie fight over a carved piano that their family has owned since slavery. Boy Willie wants to sell it to buy the Mississippi land their ancestors worked as slaves. Berniece refuses to sell it, but she also refuses to play it. Wilson uses their disagreement to argue that a family's history is not honored by locking it away or by cashing it in, but only by using it to live in the present.

The piano matters because of what is carved into it. Their uncle Doaker explains that Robert Sutter, who owned the family, traded Berniece's great-grandmother and her nine-year-old son for the piano as a gift for his wife. Her husband, Willie Boy, was a skilled carpenter, and he carved their faces into the wood along with scenes from the family's history. In 1911 Berniece's father, Boy Charles, took the piano out of the Sutter house on the Fourth of July, and he was burned to death in a boxcar for it. So the piano is not furniture. It is a record of the family being sold and of a man dying to take that record back.

Boy Willie's argument is practical, and Wilson does not make it foolish. He points out that the piano just sits in Doaker's parlor in Pittsburgh, while land is something a person can build a future on. If he owns Sutter's land, he stands on equal footing with the family that once owned his. Selling the piano is his way of turning the past into power, and his energy and humor make the audience want him to succeed.

Berniece's position seems more respectful, but Wilson shows that it is also a trap. She has not touched the keys since their mother, Mama Ola, died. She says her mother polished the piano with her tears for seventeen years, and she is afraid that playing it will wake the spirits of the dead. She keeps the piano as a shrine, which means she also keeps the grief frozen inside it. Her daughter Maretha is learning to play, but Berniece will not tell her the story of the carvings. The past is protected, and it is also silent.

The ending settles the argument in a way neither sibling expected. Sutter's ghost has been haunting the house, and Boy Willie wrestles it but cannot beat it alone. Berniece sits down at the piano and plays for the first time in years, calling on her ancestors by name to help. The ghost leaves. The piano finally does what it could not do as a shrine or as cash: it becomes a living instrument again. Boy Willie drops the sale and leaves to catch his train, warning Berniece that if she and Maretha stop playing, he and Sutter might both come back.

The play's title tells us that inheritance is something you have to learn and practice. The disagreement between the siblings shows two wrong ways to carry history, and the ending shows a third way, where the family's past is called out loud and used to protect the people living now.

How it scored

1/1A — The thesis makes a clear, arguable interpretation: Wilson rejects both hiding the family's history and selling it, and shows that the past is honored only by using it. That is a claim about the whole play, not a restatement of the prompt.
4/4B — Specific evidence runs throughout: Sutter's trade, Willie Boy's carvings, Boy Charles's death in 1911, Mama Ola's seventeen years of polishing, Maretha's lessons, the ghost, and Boy Willie's final warning. Each paragraph explains how its evidence moves the argument, so the line of reasoning goes from the piano's history, to each sibling's view, to the ending that resolves them.
0/1C — The essay is perceptive, and it is fair to Boy Willie, but it settles the conflict too neatly as 'two wrong ways and one right way.' It never asks why the play lets Boy Willie leave still believing in the land, or how the 1936 Great Migration setting shapes the siblings' choices. With that tension developed, this essay would earn the point.
The Disputed Inheritance · mid-scoring response3/6

In the short story Everyday Use by Alice Walker, a mother and her two daughters disagree about what the family quilts mean, and this disagreement contributes to the meaning of the work as a whole.

Dee is the older daughter who went away to school. When she comes home she has changed her name to Wangero and says she does not want to be named after the people who oppress her. Mama points out that she was named after her aunt, Big Dee, who was named after Grandma Dee. This shows that Dee doesn't really understand her own family history even though she says she cares about heritage. She is trying to connect with Africa but she ignores the people who are right in front of her.

When Dee sees the quilts she wants them because Grandma Dee and Big Dee pieced them by hand, and they have scraps from Great Grandpa Ezra's Civil War uniform in them. She says Maggie would be backward enough to put them to everyday use and they would be in rags in five years. Dee wants to hang them on the wall. She probably also knows they are worth a lot of money now because handmade things are popular, so she wants to sell them or show them off to her friends. This shows Dee thinks of her heritage as something to look at, not something to live.

Maggie is the opposite. She has burn scars from the house fire and she is very shy, but she knows how to quilt because Grandma Dee and Big Dee taught her. When Mama says she promised the quilts to Maggie, Maggie says Dee can have them because she can remember Grandma Dee without the quilts. This shows that for Maggie, heritage is in memory and in skills, not in objects.

At the end Mama hugs Maggie, takes the quilts away from Dee, and puts them in Maggie's lap. Dee tells Mama she doesn't understand her heritage. But the reader can see that Mama and Maggie are the ones who really understand it, because they use it every day. The title Everyday Use shows that Walker agrees with Maggie.

So the quilts show the difference between Dee and Maggie and what heritage really means.

How it scored

0/1A — The opening sentence only restates the prompt: the disagreement 'contributes to the meaning of the work as a whole' without saying what that meaning is. Readers look for a thesis anywhere in the essay, but the last line is too vague to count, and the clearer idea in the third paragraph is never presented as the essay's claim.
3/4B — The body does build a line of reasoning: Dee treats heritage as display, Maggie carries it in memory and skill, and the title sides with Maggie. Most evidence is specific and explained. It falls short of 4 because the claim that Dee wants to sell the quilts has no support in the story, since she says she wants to hang them, and the name paragraph is only loosely tied to the quilts.
0/1C — The reading stays one-sided: Dee is simply wrong and Maggie simply right. The essay never considers why Mama has saved the quilts unused for years or what Dee's interest in Africa might say about her generation, so there is no complexity to reward.

Where points die

Writing a thesis that just repeats the prompt, such as 'the routine contributes to the meaning of the work as a whole.' Row A needs your actual reading. Finish the sentence 'and so the work shows that...' with a claim someone could disagree with. 'Stevens's routine shields him from grief but costs him his life's chances' is a thesis. 'Stevens has a routine' is a topic.

Retelling the plot in order and adding 'this shows' after each scene. Summary caps you at 1 or 2 in Row B. Pick three or four scenes that each prove a different step of your argument. Spend more words explaining why a scene matters than describing what happens in it.

Giving a character a motive the text never shows, such as saying Dee in 'Everyday Use' plans to sell the quilts when she only says she wants to hang them. Check what the scene and the character's own words actually support. Point to the line or moment that backs up a motive, and when you go beyond it, mark your inference as an inference.

Bringing in a reading the work does not support, like a hidden money motive, a social message about industry, or a biographical guess drawn from one metaphor. Every big claim needs a scene behind it. If no character mentions cost, do not build a paragraph on cost. A figurative word, such as calling someone's criticism surgical, describes a style, not the person's job.

Using literary terms loosely: calling every surprise dramatic irony, or calling a narrator omniscient when we only see one character's mind. Dramatic irony means the audience knows something a character does not. Situational irony means events turn out opposite to what was expected. Omniscient narration enters several minds, while limited narration stays with one. A wrong label weakens your commentary, so name a device only when you are sure, and always explain its effect.

Chasing the sophistication point with fancy words or one grand line about society in the conclusion. Row C rewards sustained complex thinking. Pick one real tension in the work, such as a sympathetic character who does harm, and carry it through the body paragraphs. Readers award it when the whole essay thinks at that level.

Score your own response

0 / 6

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.