Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Sociological observation

Sociological observation appears in 10 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Sociological observation is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage. "What the sociologist observes at the intersection of Fifth and Main at 5:17 p.m. on a Tuesday is not chaos but choreography. The pedestrians do not collide, though they number in hundreds and share a sidewalk twelve feet wide. They do not speak, yet they communicate — a slight shift of the shoulder, a half-step deceleration, an almost imperceptible nod that says 'you first' without the expenditure of a single syllable. This is the social contract in its most elemental and beautiful form: not the grand compact of constitutions and legislatures but the micro-negotiations of bodies in shared space, each yielding precisely enough autonomy to permit collective motion without collective collision. Hobbes was wrong. The state of nature is not war. It is this — this intricate, unspoken, unrehearsed ballet of mutual accommodation." The author's allusion to Hobbes serves primarily to
  1. Aacknowledge that the pedestrian scene is an unusual exception rather than a representative pattern of everyday behavior
  2. Bcite a widely known philosophical claim about human nature only to overturn it with contrary evidenceCorrect
  3. Cshift the passage's focus from concrete street-level observation to abstract speculation about political philosophy
  4. Ddemonstrate the author's broad familiarity with major works of Enlightenment political philosophy

Why B is right

The allusion to Hobbes ('the state of nature is war') cites a recognizable philosophical claim that the author's pedestrian observation directly contradicts. By invoking and then overturning Hobbes's famous thesis, the author uses the allusion as a foil that makes the counter-argument — that natural human interaction is cooperative rather than combative — more striking.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the author presents the pedestrian behavior as evidence of a universal human tendency toward cooperation, not as an unusual exception to normal behavior.
C
Incorrect because the Hobbes reference connects the concrete street-level observation back to broader theory rather than being a mere shift away from it; the observation is the evidence, and Hobbes is the counterargument it refutes.
D
Incorrect because the allusion serves the argument's substance — refuting Hobbes's claim — rather than functioning as a display of the author's reading.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.