Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Argument structure

Argument structure appears in 40 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Argument structure is tested

Example 1Harder
Read the following passage, then answer the question. The argument that standardized testing discriminates against students from lower-income families is often presented as a reason to eliminate standardized testing. The argument proves too much. If standardized testing discriminates against lower-income students, so does the GPA, which is influenced by access to tutoring, AP course availability, and teacher quality — all of which correlate with socioeconomic status. So does the extracurricular record, which requires time, transportation, and money. So does the application essay, which benefits from coaching that typically costs hundreds of dollars per session. If we follow the logic of 'this metric disadvantages lower-income students' consistently, we arrive at a college admissions process with no metrics at all — which is either random selection or judgment entirely at the discretion of admissions officers, neither of which obviously serves lower-income students better. The author's logical strategy in this passage is best described as...
  1. AStraw man argumentation, misrepresenting the critics' actual position in order to make it easier to refute and dismiss
  2. BReductio ad absurdum, extending the critics' own principle to its logical conclusion, one the critics themselves would rejectCorrect
  3. CTu quoque, accusing critics of harboring the same bias they attribute to standardized testing, to discredit their critique
  4. DFalse dichotomy, presenting only two alternatives, keep all metrics or drop them all, while ignoring any middle ground

Why B is right

The author takes the critics' principle ('this metric disadvantages lower-income students') and applies it consistently to all other admissions metrics, showing it would eliminate everything — a conclusion the critics presumably would not endorse. This is a reductio ad absurdum structure, matching B.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
The author engages the critics' actual argument (the discrimination concern) directly; no misrepresentation is involved.
C
The author does not accuse the critics of bias; the argument is about the logical consequences of applying their principle consistently.
D
The author arrives at two endpoints through logical extension of the critics' principle, not by asserting them as the only options; the structure is reductio, not false dichotomy.
Example 2Medium
Read the following passage and answer the question. Critics of expanded immigration often invoke the metaphor of the lifeboat: the nation, they argue, is a vessel of limited capacity, and admitting too many passengers will swamp the boat and drown everyone aboard. The metaphor is vivid, intuitive, and fundamentally misleading. A lifeboat is a fixed, finite object — it cannot grow. An economy is not. Immigrants do not merely occupy space; they create it. They start businesses at higher rates than native-born citizens. They fill labor shortages in agriculture, construction, healthcare, and technology. They pay into Social Security and Medicare, often without the prospect of ever collecting benefits. The lifeboat metaphor assumes a zero-sum world in which every new arrival diminishes the share available to those already present. But the economy is not zero-sum. It is, and has always been, expandable. The author's response to the lifeboat metaphor is best characterized as
  1. Aa concession that the metaphor is partially valid for certain heavily strained economic sectors
  2. Ban emotional appeal that plays on readers' fears while ignoring the legitimate concerns underlying the metaphor
  3. Ca refutation that rejects the metaphor's assumption of a fixed-capacity economyCorrect
  4. Da personal attack on the motives and character of those who invoke the lifeboat metaphor

Why C is right

The author systematically dismantles the lifeboat metaphor by attacking its foundational premise: that the economy, like a lifeboat, has a fixed capacity. By arguing that the economy is expandable and that immigrants contribute to its growth, the author refutes the fixed-capacity assumption on which the metaphor depends.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the author rejects the metaphor's premise entirely rather than conceding its partial validity.
B
Incorrect because the author provides specific economic evidence (business creation, labor shortages, tax contributions) rather than relying on emotional appeals.
D
Incorrect because the author critiques the metaphor's logic, not the character or motives of those who employ it.
Example 3Medium
Read the following passage and answer the question. "The critic who praises everything praises nothing. Applause without discernment is noise. A review that calls every album 'groundbreaking' has rendered the word meaningless, has contributed to the slow inflation of superlatives that makes it harder each year to say something true about music. Criticism is not cruelty. Criticism is the act of taking the work seriously enough to measure it, to hold it to a standard, to say: this matters, and because it matters, I will tell you where it fails. The musician who has never received an honest negative review has never had a real reader. They have had fans, which is a different thing entirely." The distinction the author draws between 'fans' and 'readers' at the close of the passage primarily functions as:
  1. AAn antithesis that crystallizes the passage's central argument about the purpose of criticismCorrect
  2. BA concession that fan culture has merit alongside critical culture
  3. CAn appositive that clarifies the meaning of the term 'honest negative review'
  4. DA definition of 'reader' borrowed from literary theory to lend the argument academic weight

Why A is right

The closing distinction — 'fans, which is a different thing entirely' — sets up an antithesis between uncritical admiration (fans) and engaged, discerning attention (readers). This contrast encapsulates the passage's argument that genuine criticism requires standards and honesty, unlike mere approval. It is not a concession, an appositive, or a borrowed term, but a pointed contrast that resolves the argument.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
The passage does not concede merit to fan culture. The phrase 'which is a different thing entirely' implies inferiority, not equivalence.
C
An appositive renames or re-explains a preceding noun in the same sentence. The fan/reader distinction appears in a separate sentence and functions as a contrast, not a clarifying restatement.
D
No specific literary theory is referenced. The distinction is the author's own rhetorical move, not a borrowed technical term.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.