Read the following passage and answer the question.
A student is writing a research paper about the effects of social media on political polarization. She has gathered the following notes:
- A 2023 university study found that deactivating Facebook for four weeks before an election reduced political polarization by 4.7% among participants but did not change their voting behavior.
- A 2024 analysis of social media data found that only 1% of users generate 80% of political content, and this small group is significantly more ideologically extreme than the general population.
- A 2022 public opinion survey found that 62% of Americans believe social media has a mostly negative effect on the country's politics, while 10% say it has a mostly positive effect.
- Another university study found that social media algorithms amplify outrage-inducing content because it generates higher engagement, regardless of its factual accuracy.
The student wants to argue that social media's effect on political polarization is real but more limited than commonly perceived. Which combination of evidence most effectively supports this specific argument?
- AThe deactivation study and the content-analysis study, because together they show a modest but real effect and reveal that extreme content comes from a small, unrepresentative minority of usersCorrect
- BThe opinion survey and the algorithm study, because together they show that most Americans view social media negatively and that its algorithms are deliberately designed to favor content that inflames political division
- CThe opinion survey alone, because a clear majority of Americans reporting that social media harms politics is itself strong evidence that its polarizing effects are widespread and severe
- DThe algorithm study and the deactivation study, because they both prove that social media algorithms are the primary and dominant cause of political division across the United States
Why A is right
The student's argument requires evidence showing that polarization effects exist (the deactivation study's 4.7% reduction confirms a real effect) but are limited (the 4.7% is modest, and the content-analysis data shows extreme content comes from just 1% of users, meaning most users are not generating polarizing material). Together, these sources support the 'real but limited' thesis.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the opinion survey measures public perception, not actual polarization effects, and the algorithm study emphasizes algorithmic amplification—both suggest social media's effects are substantial, which contradicts the 'more limited than commonly perceived' argument.
- C
- Incorrect because public perception is not equivalent to measured effect; the opinion survey shows what people believe, not what research has demonstrated, and a single source about perception does not support a nuanced empirical claim.
- D
- Incorrect because the deactivation study found a modest 4.7% effect, which does not prove social media is the 'primary cause' of political division; this characterization overstates the evidence and contradicts the 'limited' component of the argument.