Read the following passage, then answer the question.
Thomas Paine wrote Common Sense not for scholars but for shipwrights, farmers, and innkeepers. He published it as a pamphlet — cheap, portable, and anonymous — precisely because he understood that the argument he was making was too dangerous for a gentleman's calling card. The prose he chose was equally deliberate. Where the political tracts of the day were laden with classical allusions and Latin quotations, Paine wrote in plain English: 'A long habit of not thinking a thing wrong gives it a superficial appearance of being right.' Sentences like this were not accidents. Paine was doing something radical with style itself: he was saying that the people capable of self-governance were the same people capable of reading, judging, and deciding — and that they did not need learned intermediaries to explain their own rights to them. The medium was the argument.
The statement 'The medium was the argument' at the end of the passage functions primarily as...
- Aa compressed thesis capturing the passage's claim that Paine's style was itself a political actCorrect
- Ba direct quotation of Marshall McLuhan's famous phrase, borrowed here to describe eighteenth-century pamphlet publishing
- Ca concession that the content of Common Sense mattered less than its mode of distribution among the public
- Da transitional phrase that introduces a new claim about the limitations of pamphlet publishing as a medium
Why A is right
The final sentence distills the passage's central argument: Paine's choice of medium (the cheap pamphlet in plain English) was not merely a vehicle for his political ideas but was itself an enactment of those ideas — the belief that ordinary people could govern themselves and required no learned intermediaries. Style and distribution were not incidental; they were the argument.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- The passage does not present the line as a direct quotation from McLuhan; it is the author's own synthesis that merely echoes McLuhan's famous formulation.
- C
- The passage does not subordinate content to medium; it argues that they were inseparable — the medium embodied and advanced the content.
- D
- The final sentence is a concluding synthesis, not a transitional phrase; no new claim follows it, and no limitations of the medium are discussed.