Read the following passage, then answer the question.
The senator's floor speech lasted forty minutes. He quoted the Bible three times, the Constitution once, and the Founding Fathers twice. He invoked his late mother, who had 'worked two jobs so her children wouldn't have to.' He described a constituent who had 'looked him in the eye' at a town hall and spoken about struggling to pay for medication. He cited no studies. He presented no data. He offered no mechanism by which the bill he opposed would cause harm or the bill he favored would cause improvement. When it was over, he received a standing ovation from one side of the aisle. I do not blame him. He was speaking in the idiom available to him, to an audience for which that idiom is persuasive. What I am interested in is why that idiom is persuasive, and what it tells us about the limits of democratic deliberation.
The author's characterization of the senator's speech as the 'idiom available to him' primarily serves to...
- Asuggest that biblical and constitutional references are always more persuasive than empirical evidence in legislative contexts
- Bexcuse the senator from responsibility for the limitations of his argument by attributing them to cultural constraints beyond his control
- Cestablish the author's sympathy for the senator's position before presenting a more rigorous version of the same argument
- Dshift from critique of an individual to analysis of the broader discursive conditions that make non-evidential rhetoric effectiveCorrect
Why D is right
The phrase 'idiom available to him' moves the analysis from the individual senator to the systemic conditions — the audience, the norms of the forum — that make this type of rhetoric effective. The author says 'I do not blame him' explicitly, redirecting toward structural analysis rather than individual criticism, matching B.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The author observes that this idiom is persuasive to a particular audience; no universal claim about its superiority to evidence is made.
- B
- The author does not frame this as an excuse but as a sociological observation; the tone is analytical, not apologetic.
- C
- The author does not endorse the senator's position; the interest is in understanding why the rhetoric works, not in advancing its substantive claims.