Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Nuclear disarmament

Nuclear disarmament appears in 5 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Nuclear disarmament is tested

Example 1Easier
Read the following passage and answer the question. Nuclear disarmament advocates have long argued that the doctrine of mutually assured destruction—MAD, in the grimly appropriate acronym—is a form of collective insanity rationalized as strategy. The doctrine holds that nuclear war is prevented by each side's certainty that launching a first strike would trigger a retaliatory strike of equal or greater magnitude, destroying both nations. The logic, such as it is, depends on several assumptions: that decision-makers are rational, that communication systems function perfectly under extreme stress, that no mechanical failure or false alarm will be mistaken for an actual launch, and that no rogue actor will ever gain control of a weapon. Each assumption has, at various points in the Cold War and after, been violated. The Stanislav Petrov incident of 1983, in which a Soviet officer chose to ignore a false satellite alarm rather than initiate a retaliatory strike, demonstrates that humanity's survival has depended not on the doctrine's logic but on the judgment of individual human beings who, in moments of crisis, chose to disbelieve their own systems. The Stanislav Petrov example functions in the argument as
  1. Aa counterexample showing that survival depended on individual judgment rather than the doctrine's systemic logicCorrect
  2. Ba technical analysis of the satellite systems used in Soviet early warning networks during the Cold War
  3. Can appeal to Russian patriotism intended to build solidarity between American and Russian disarmament advocates
  4. Devidence that the MAD doctrine succeeded because rational actors like Petrov correctly followed official protocol under pressure

Why A is right

The Petrov example shows that the MAD doctrine's assumptions (rational actors, perfect communication, no false alarms) failed in practice, and survival depended on one person's judgment defying the system, not on the doctrine's logic working as designed. This undermines the doctrine's systemic logic (A). The example does not analyze satellite technology (B), appeal to patriotism (C), or show the doctrine succeeding through protocol (D).
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because the passage mentions the satellite alarm as context for Petrov's decision, not as the subject of technical analysis.
C
Incorrect because the example is used analytically to critique a doctrine, not emotionally to build international solidarity.
D
Incorrect because the example shows MAD's logic failing—Petrov's decision defied protocol and the alarm system rather than confirming that rational deterrence worked as designed.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.