Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Nature writing

Nature writing appears in 17 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Nature writing is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage, then answer the question. The light in the Sonoran Desert at five in the afternoon is not like light anywhere else. It has texture — you can almost feel it pressing against your skin, warm and insistent as a hand on a shoulder. The saguaro cacti stand in it like sentinels that have been waiting since before human memory, their arms raised in postures that suggest either supplication or greeting, depending on what you brought with you when you arrived. I have come to the desert many times over thirty years, and I am no longer certain whether I come to think or to stop thinking. There is something in the silence here — not an absence of sound, for the desert is never silent, but an absence of urgency — that makes the ordinary concerns of life feel provisional, like furniture that could easily be rearranged. The desert does not care what you are worried about. This, it turns out, is exactly what some people need to hear. The author's use of figurative language in this passage primarily contributes to a sense of...
  1. Asensory immediacy and contemplative calm, inviting the reader into a meditative encounter with landscapeCorrect
  2. Bspiritual yearning, suggesting the author is searching for transcendence and communion with the natural world
  3. Cscientific precision, grounding the desert's description in carefully observed, empirically verifiable natural phenomena
  4. Dmelancholy detachment, emphasizing the author's growing estrangement from ordinary human concerns and daily routine

Why A is right

The figurative language — light with texture like 'a hand on a shoulder,' cacti as sentinels, silence as 'an absence of urgency,' concerns as furniture — creates vivid sensory experience and a tone of open, unhurried contemplation. The passage invites the reader into an encounter with the desert that is both physical and reflective.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
While the passage is reflective, it does not express overt spiritual yearning or seek transcendence; the author describes a more secular form of mental clarity.
C
The passage deliberately moves away from scientific precision; its language is metaphorical and personal, not empirical.
D
The tone is engaged and even gently humorous ('depending on what you brought with you') rather than melancholy or detached; the author is present and connected to the landscape.
Example 2Harder
Read the following passage, then answer the question. Passage 1 (from an essay on walking, 2013): A cultural critic argues, in an essay on walking, that walking is not merely locomotion but a form of thinking — a physical process that produces mental states and creative work that other postures do not. The peripatetic philosophers of ancient Athens walked while they thought; Wordsworth composed poetry while walking the Lake District; Thoreau described walking as a kind of extended meditation. The argument is not metaphorical: there is physiological evidence that walking activates particular kinds of diffuse, associative thinking that seated concentration suppresses. Passage 2 (from a cognitive scientist's blog, 2014): The research on walking and creativity that the essayist and others cite is real but modest in scope. Studies showing that walking increases divergent thinking found effects primarily for treadmill walking — not for outdoor walking specifically — and primarily for one dimension of creative thinking (fluency of idea generation) rather than for the more demanding forms of sustained concentration that writing a poem or building an argument actually requires. The anecdotes about walking philosophers are compelling but are not evidence that walking caused the thinking rather than merely accompanied it. A student writing an essay defending the Passage 1 essayist's claim using the evidence from both passages must address which specific challenge raised by Passage 2?
  1. AThat walking is primarily beneficial for physical health and that any cognitive benefits are secondary, minor, and unreliable across contexts
  2. BThat the essayist failed to acknowledge that certain ancient Greek philosophers did their most important, systematic thinking while seated in one place
  3. CThat the correlation between famous thinkers who walked and their creative productivity may reflect personality traits rather than any effect of walking itself
  4. DThat the research on walking mainly supports simple idea generation, not the sustained concentration that complex intellectual work requiresCorrect

Why D is right

Passage 2 specifically challenges the scope of the walking research: the studies show effects for one dimension of creative thinking (divergent, associative) but not for the 'more demanding forms of sustained concentration that writing a poem or building an argument actually requires.' A defense of the essayist's claim must address this gap.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Passage 2 does not dismiss cognitive benefits generally; it specifies which kinds of creativity the research does and does not support.
B
Passage 2 does not raise arguments about seated Greek philosophers; this is not a challenge in the passage.
C
The correlation/causation objection is raised regarding anecdotes ('may not have caused the thinking rather than accompanied it'), but Passage 2's more specific challenge is about the scope of the experimental research.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.