Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Logical strategy

Logical strategy appears in 4 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Logical strategy is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage, then answer the question. The public conversation about artificial intelligence tends to oscillate between two failure modes. The first is uncritical enthusiasm: AI will cure cancer, end poverty, write the great novel. The second is undifferentiated alarm: AI will take all jobs, enable totalitarianism, render human creativity obsolete. Both modes share a structural deficiency — they treat AI as a monolithic technology with uniform effects rather than as a diverse set of tools with specific capabilities, specific limitations, and specific social contexts of deployment. A language model that assists a radiologist in reading imaging studies is not the same technology as one that generates disinformation at scale, except in the superficial sense that both involve pattern-matching on large datasets. Conflating them produces analysis that is useless for either policy or practice. What is needed is not optimism or pessimism but specificity. The author's argument is primarily structured around which logical strategy?
  1. AIdentifying a shared structural deficiency in two opposing positions and proposing specificity as the correctiveCorrect
  2. BAppealing to expert consensus in AI research to establish that both enthusiasts and alarmists are scientifically misinformed
  3. CProviding a comprehensive taxonomy of AI technologies and their respective risks and benefits
  4. DPresenting a binary choice between enthusiasm and alarm, then arguing for a middle position between the two extremes

Why A is right

The author does not simply split the difference between enthusiasm and alarm but identifies the structural deficiency they share — treating AI as monolithic — and proposes specificity as the corrective. This is not a middle-ground argument but a diagnosis-and-corrective structure, matching B.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
No expert consensus is cited; the argument is logical and structural, not authority-based.
C
No taxonomy of AI types is offered; the author argues for the need for specificity without providing it.
D
The author does not advocate a middle position between the two extremes; the critique is that both share a methodological error, and the solution is specificity, not moderation.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.