Read the following passage, then answer the question.
The argument that standardized testing discriminates against students from lower-income families is often presented as a reason to eliminate standardized testing. The argument proves too much. If standardized testing discriminates against lower-income students, so does the GPA, which is influenced by access to tutoring, AP course availability, and teacher quality — all of which correlate with socioeconomic status. So does the extracurricular record, which requires time, transportation, and money. So does the application essay, which benefits from coaching that typically costs hundreds of dollars per session. If we follow the logic of 'this metric disadvantages lower-income students' consistently, we arrive at a college admissions process with no metrics at all — which is either random selection or judgment entirely at the discretion of admissions officers, neither of which obviously serves lower-income students better.
The author's logical strategy in this passage is best described as...
- AStraw man argumentation, misrepresenting the critics' actual position in order to make it easier to refute and dismiss
- BReductio ad absurdum, extending the critics' own principle to its logical conclusion, one the critics themselves would rejectCorrect
- CTu quoque, accusing critics of harboring the same bias they attribute to standardized testing, to discredit their critique
- DFalse dichotomy, presenting only two alternatives, keep all metrics or drop them all, while ignoring any middle ground
Why B is right
The author takes the critics' principle ('this metric disadvantages lower-income students') and applies it consistently to all other admissions metrics, showing it would eliminate everything — a conclusion the critics presumably would not endorse. This is a reductio ad absurdum structure, matching B.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The author engages the critics' actual argument (the discrimination concern) directly; no misrepresentation is involved.
- C
- The author does not accuse the critics of bias; the argument is about the logical consequences of applying their principle consistently.
- D
- The author arrives at two endpoints through logical extension of the critics' principle, not by asserting them as the only options; the structure is reductio, not false dichotomy.