Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Induced demand

Induced demand appears in 3 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Induced demand is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage. "The town council approved the highway expansion on the grounds that it would reduce commute times. The evidence supporting this claim comes from traffic engineering models that assume a fixed number of cars. But the models are wrong — not because the mathematics is flawed, but because the assumption is false. When you widen a highway, you do not accommodate existing traffic; you invite new traffic. This is induced demand, and it has been documented in every major highway expansion since the 1960s. The Katy Freeway in Houston was expanded to twenty-three lanes — the widest highway in the world — and commute times increased by 25%. Los Angeles added lanes to the 405 and travel times grew longer. The evidence consistently shows that building more highway capacity generates more driving, as surely as building more restaurant seating generates more dining." The author undermines the traffic engineering models by identifying which specific flaw in their reasoning?
  1. AThe models rely on outdated traffic-count methods rather than the computer simulations that most transportation agencies now use
  2. BThe models fail to account for seasonal fluctuations in traffic volume, such as holiday travel or summer construction projects
  3. CThe models treat the number of cars as fixed, when in fact that number rises in direct response to the added highway capacity itselfCorrect
  4. DThe models were produced by engineers whose funding came from the highway construction industry, which biased their conclusions

Why C is right

The author identifies the key flaw: the models assume a fixed number of cars, but highway expansion itself changes that number by inducing new demand. The variable the models hold constant (traffic volume) is actually responsive to the intervention being modeled (highway expansion), making the models fundamentally incapable of predicting the actual outcome.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the author states the mathematics is not flawed; the problem is the false assumption underlying the models, not their calculation methods.
B
Incorrect because the identified flaw is the static assumption about car volume, not seasonal variation.
D
Incorrect because the author does not raise conflicts of interest; the critique is methodological, not institutional.
Example 2Easier
Read the following passage and answer the question. A student is writing a persuasive essay arguing that public transportation investment should be prioritized over highway expansion. She has assembled the following notes: Note 1: The Texas Transportation Institute calculates that the average American commuter loses 54 hours per year to traffic congestion, costing the economy $87 billion annually in wasted fuel and lost productivity. Note 2: A comprehensive study published in Transportation Research found that every $1 invested in public transit generates $4 in economic returns through increased employment access, reduced congestion, and decreased vehicle emissions. Note 3: Research from the University of Toronto demonstrates the phenomenon of "induced demand"—when new highway lanes are added, traffic increases to fill them within five to ten years, returning congestion to pre-expansion levels. Note 4: The American Public Transportation Association reports that communities with robust public transit systems produce 45% fewer carbon emissions per capita from transportation than auto-dependent communities. The student wants to preemptively address the likely counterargument that highway expansion is the most direct solution to traffic congestion. Which source most effectively refutes this counterargument?
  1. ANote 1, because it quantifies the economic cost of congestion
  2. BNote 4, because it shows that public transit communities have lower emissions
  3. CNote 2, because it demonstrates the economic returns of public transit investment
  4. DNote 3, because it provides empirical evidence that highway expansion fails to reduce congestion long-term due to induced demandCorrect

Why D is right

The counterargument is that highway expansion directly solves congestion. Note 3 directly refutes this by presenting the concept of 'induced demand'—empirical evidence showing that new highway lanes attract additional traffic that fills the added capacity within five to ten years, returning congestion to previous levels. This evidence demonstrates that the counterargument's premise (more lanes = less congestion) is empirically false.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because Note 1 quantifies the congestion problem but does not address whether highway expansion solves it; establishing the problem's cost does not refute a proposed solution.
B
Incorrect because Note 4 addresses environmental benefits of transit, not the congestion-reduction claim of the highway expansion counterargument; emissions and congestion are related but distinct issues.
C
Incorrect because Note 2 supports the student's thesis (invest in transit) but does not directly refute the highway expansion counterargument; showing that transit has good returns does not demonstrate that highway expansion has poor ones.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.