Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Immigration

Immigration appears in 12 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Immigration is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage, then answer the question. Consider Rosa Gutierrez, who crossed the border at nineteen with two hundred dollars and a ninth-grade education. Twenty-three years later, she owns a bakery that employs eleven people, pays $47,000 annually in local taxes, and sponsors a Little League team that has won the regional championship three times. Her story is not unusual. In the border communities of South Texas, immigrant-owned businesses account for 34% of all small business revenue. Rosa's success does not prove that immigration policy should be reformed — no single anecdote carries that weight. But it illustrates a principle that aggregate data confirms: immigrant entrepreneurship generates economic activity that extends far beyond the immigrants themselves. The bakery's flour comes from a mill in Kansas. Its ovens were manufactured in Ohio. Its delivery van was purchased from a dealership in San Antonio. Rosa's American dream is not a solo performance. It is an ensemble production, and the entire cast benefits. The author acknowledges that 'no single anecdote carries that weight' most likely in order to
  1. Aacknowledge that anecdotal evidence alone is insufficient, then reinforce the story with statistical supportCorrect
  2. Bconcede that the case for immigration reform rests on weak evidence that no amount of subsequent statistical support can strengthen
  3. Ctransition from Rosa's individual experience to a broader legal and legislative discussion of immigration reform policy
  4. Dundermine Rosa's story by implying that her success is a statistical outlier with no bearing on the wider immigration debate

Why A is right

The acknowledgment functions as a concession that strengthens the argument: by admitting the limitation of anecdotal evidence, the author preempts the counterargument and then immediately supplements the anecdote with aggregate data (34% of small business revenue). This combination of narrative and statistics produces a more persuasive case than either alone.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because the author does not concede that the case is weak or unsalvageable; the concession about anecdotal limitations is immediately followed by statistical evidence that confirms and strengthens the argument's central claim.
C
Incorrect because the passage does not shift to a legal or legislative discussion; the author moves from anecdote to aggregate economic data, maintaining the focus on entrepreneurship rather than law or policy mechanics.
D
Incorrect because the author does not undermine Rosa's story or dismiss it as an outlier; the acknowledgment is followed by supporting data that validates the principle her story illustrates, strengthening rather than weakening the example.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.