Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Historical evidence

Historical evidence appears in 9 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Historical evidence is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage, then answer the question. The speed at which social media companies have been asked to solve the problem of misinformation reveals something important about our expectations of technology and our expectations of democracy. We expect Facebook to do in months what democratic societies have failed to do in centuries: create reliable shared standards for truth, develop mechanisms for distinguishing credible from non-credible information, and enforce those standards without creating censorship. These are tasks that free societies have never solved well. The town square of the eighteenth century was full of pamphlets making claims that were false or misleading. The printing press created a crisis of misinformation that took roughly a century to partially resolve through the development of professional journalism, media criticism, and public education. We are asking social media companies to solve that problem on a quarterly earnings cycle. The author includes the reference to eighteenth-century pamphlets and the printing press most likely in order to...
  1. Aprovide historical perspective suggesting that misinformation crises are not novel and generally require decades of institutional development to resolveCorrect
  2. Bestablish that the printing press disrupted its era as severely as social media disrupts ours, and that this parallel vindicates social media companies' failures
  3. Cargue that misinformation is a natural and permanent feature of any information-rich society that no amount of policy or technology can meaningfully reduce
  4. Dcelebrate the historical development of professional journalism and media literacy as a model that social media companies should directly replicate today

Why A is right

The historical reference serves as analogical evidence for the author's argument that we are demanding of social media companies what it took democratic societies centuries to partially achieve. The eighteenth-century parallel is not about celebrating journalism or vindicating tech companies — it is about establishing that the problem is old, deep, and resistant to quick resolution, which makes the expectation of a 'quarterly earnings cycle' solution unrealistic.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
The passage does not vindicate social media companies; the comparison is used to argue against unrealistic timelines, not to excuse companies from responsibility.
C
The author does not argue misinformation is permanent and unreducible; the passage notes the printing press crisis was 'partially resolved,' implying resolution is possible — just slow.
D
The passage mentions professional journalism as part of what took a century to develop but does not advocate for it as a model; the focus is on the time scale, not the specific mechanisms.
Example 2Easier
Read the following passage and answer the question. A student is preparing a debate arguing that the four-day workweek should be adopted as standard practice. She has collected the following evidence: Source 1: Iceland conducted the world's largest trial of a four-day workweek (2015-2019), involving 2,500 workers across diverse industries. Productivity remained the same or improved in most workplaces, while worker well-being dramatically increased. Source 2: A 2023 pilot program involving 61 companies in the United Kingdom found that revenue increased by 1.4% on average during the trial, 71% of employees reported lower burnout, and 92% of participating companies chose to continue the four-day schedule after the trial ended. Source 3: The National Bureau of Economic Research published a study finding that the five-day, forty-hour workweek was established not by productivity research but by a 1938 political compromise (the Fair Labor Standards Act), and that no rigorous study at the time established forty hours as the optimal number for productivity. Source 4: The U.S. Chamber of Commerce has argued that a four-day workweek would reduce output, increase labor costs, and harm American competitiveness in the global economy. The student wants to undermine the assumption that the current five-day workweek is based on evidence about optimal productivity. Which source most directly accomplishes this?
  1. ASource 2, because the UK companies chose to continue the four-day schedule
  2. BSource 1, because the Iceland trial showed productivity remained stable with fewer hours
  3. CSource 3, because it reveals that the five-day workweek originated from political compromise rather than productivity research, undermining the assumption that it is evidence-basedCorrect
  4. DSource 4, because the Chamber of Commerce's opposition proves that the five-day week is economically optimal

Why C is right

The student's specific goal is to undermine the assumption that the five-day workweek is based on productivity evidence. Source 3 directly addresses this by revealing that the forty-hour, five-day week was established by political compromise (the 1938 Fair Labor Standards Act), not by productivity research. This historical fact directly undermines the assumption that the current schedule reflects evidence about optimal work patterns.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because companies choosing to continue a four-day schedule shows the model's viability but does not address the historical assumption about why the five-day week exists.
B
Incorrect because while Source 1 provides evidence that fewer hours do not reduce productivity, it does not directly address the historical basis of the five-day workweek; it shows an alternative works but does not explain why the current standard lacks evidentiary foundation.
D
Incorrect because the Chamber of Commerce's opposition is an argument for maintaining the status quo, not evidence that the status quo is evidence-based; opposition to change does not validate the original basis for the current system.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.