Read the following passage, then answer the question.
The argument for universal pre-kindergarten cannot rest on sentiment alone. Those who advocate for early childhood education because 'children deserve the best start' are making an ethical claim that, however admirable, fails to persuade legislators who think in fiscal years rather than developmental stages. The Perry Preschool Study offers firmer ground. Tracking participants over four decades, the study found that children who attended a high-quality preschool program earned, on average, $20,800 more per year by age 40, were 46% less likely to have served jail time, and were 20% more likely to hold steady employment. The return on investment was calculated at $7 to $12 for every dollar spent. These are not the numbers of a social experiment; they are the numbers of a sound investment. When we frame early education as a cost rather than an expenditure, we have already lost the rhetorical battle. Reframing it as an investment — one with a documented, multi-decade return — transforms the conversation from charity to strategy.
The author includes the specific statistics from the Perry Preschool Study most likely in order to
- Acriticize legislators for prioritizing economic data over children's emotional and developmental well-being
- Bdemonstrate that the Perry Preschool Study is the most rigorous and widely cited longitudinal study in the history of educational research
- Cargue that every child who attends a high-quality preschool program will earn a significantly higher income as an adult
- Dshift the argument from moral sentiment to empirical evidence that appeals to fiscally minded decision-makersCorrect
Why D is right
The passage explicitly sets up a rhetorical problem — ethical arguments do not persuade fiscal legislators — and then presents the Perry Preschool statistics as the solution. The data (earnings, incarceration rates, ROI) is chosen to speak the language of legislators who 'think in fiscal years,' reframing the issue from moral sentiment to documented economic return.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the author does not criticize legislators for prioritizing economic data over emotional or developmental concerns; the author instead strategically adopts economic framing to meet legislators on their own terms.
- B
- Incorrect because the author does not compare the study to other research or claim it is the most rigorous and widely cited study in the field's history; the statistics are included for their persuasive utility in a specific rhetorical context, not to rank the study's overall standing.
- C
- Incorrect because the author cites averages and percentages, not a guarantee for every individual child; the statistics describe group-level outcomes among study participants, not a prediction that each child who attends preschool will see a significantly higher income.