Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Evidence evaluation

Evidence evaluation appears in 13 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Evidence evaluation is tested

Example 1Harder
Read the following passage and answer the question. Defenders of standardized testing argue that these exams provide an objective measure of student achievement, a common yardstick that allows colleges to compare applicants from different schools with different grading standards. This argument has a surface logic that crumbles under scrutiny. The SAT does not measure achievement; it measures preparation, and preparation is a commodity that can be purchased. Students from affluent families spend an average of $6,000 on test preparation — private tutors, prep courses, practice exams — while students from low-income families rely on whatever free resources their under-funded schools can provide. The predictive validity of SAT scores for college success, once the cornerstone of the test's defense, has been shown in multiple studies to be weaker than high school GPA alone. We are not comparing students on a level playing field. We are comparing their families' bank accounts and calling the result merit. The author's argument would be most weakened by evidence showing that
  1. Astudents from affluent families also tend to earn higher high school GPAs than students from low-income families, since private schools often inflate grades
  2. BSAT scores predict college success more accurately than any other single admissions factor, regardless of a student's family incomeCorrect
  3. Cthe College Board has offered free SAT preparation materials through Khan Academy since 2015, and many students use them
  4. Dmany selective colleges have adopted test-optional admissions policies in recent years amid concerns about testing bias

Why B is right

The author's argument rests on two pillars: (1) SAT scores reflect purchased preparation, not merit, and (2) SAT scores are weaker predictors of college success than GPA. Evidence that SAT scores predict college success better than any other factor — regardless of income — would directly undermine the second pillar and weaken the implication that the test merely reflects economic advantage.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because this would actually strengthen the author's point by suggesting that GPA is also influenced by wealth, but it does not address whether the SAT specifically is a valid measure.
C
Incorrect because the availability of free materials does not address the core argument about unequal preparation; the author's point is about spending disparities ($6,000 vs. free resources), not the absence of any free resources.
D
Incorrect because colleges adopting test-optional policies would support the author's skepticism about the test, not weaken it.
Example 2Medium
Read the following passage and answer the question. A policy analyst is preparing a brief about the effectiveness of minimum wage increases. She has collected the following sources: Source 1: A 2023 Congressional Budget Office report estimated that raising the federal minimum wage to $15 would lift 900,000 people out of poverty but eliminate 1.4 million jobs. Source 2: A University of California, Berkeley study of minimum wage increases in six cities found that restaurant employment remained stable after wage increases, contradicting predictions of job losses. Source 3: A National Bureau of Economic Research paper found that minimum wage increases in rural areas with lower costs of living produced greater job losses than identical increases in urban areas. Source 4: Bureau of Labor Statistics data showing that 58% of minimum wage workers are between ages 16 and 24, and 63% work part-time. The analyst wants to argue that minimum wage policy should be tailored to regional economic conditions rather than set at a single national level. Which sources best support her argument?
  1. ASources 1 and 4, because they demonstrate the demographic characteristics of minimum wage workers and overall job impact projections
  2. BSources 2 and 3, because the Berkeley study shows wage increases working in cities while the NBER paper shows they cause greater harm in rural areas, together demonstrating that regional differences matterCorrect
  3. CSources 2 and 4, because they show that restaurants did not lose jobs and that most minimum wage workers are young part-time employees
  4. DSources 1 and 2, because they present contradictory findings that prove no conclusions can be drawn about minimum wage effects

Why B is right

The analyst's argument is that minimum wage policy should vary by region. Source 2 (Berkeley study of cities) shows that wage increases worked in urban areas without job losses, while Source 3 (NBER paper) shows that identical increases caused greater job losses in rural areas. Together, they provide direct evidence that the same policy produces different outcomes in different regional contexts, supporting the case for regional tailoring.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because Source 1 presents a national aggregate estimate and Source 4 provides demographics, neither of which directly addresses regional variation—the core of the analyst's argument.
C
Incorrect because while Source 2 is relevant (showing urban success), Source 4 about demographics does not address regional economic differences; this combination supports a different argument about who earns minimum wage, not where policy should differ.
D
Incorrect because contradictory findings do not prove that 'no conclusions can be drawn'; they suggest that context matters—precisely the analyst's point—but this answer choice mischaracterizes the relationship between the sources.
Example 3Harder
Read the following passage and answer the question. A journalist is writing an article about the effectiveness of body-worn cameras on police officers. She has collected the following information: Source 1: A randomized controlled trial in Washington, D.C. (2017) involving 2,224 officers found no statistically significant difference in use-of-force incidents or civilian complaints between officers wearing cameras and those not wearing them. Source 2: A study of the Rialto, California, police department (2012) found that use-of-force incidents dropped 59% and civilian complaints dropped 87% after body cameras were introduced. Source 3: A meta-analysis of 70 body camera studies (2023) concluded that cameras reduce use-of-force incidents by an average of 9.6% but that effects vary dramatically based on department policies regarding when officers must activate cameras. Source 4: A survey of 500 police officers found that 78% felt body cameras changed their behavior during interactions with the public, with most reporting increased professionalism. Which source would be most useful for explaining why Sources 1 and 2 produced such different results?
  1. ASource 4, because officers' self-reported behavior changes directly explain why measured outcomes differed between the two departments studied
  2. BSource 2, because the Rialto study's dramatic 59% drop in force incidents proves body cameras always reduce misconduct once departments implement them properly
  3. CSource 1, because its much larger sample size makes its null result more statistically reliable than Source 2's, resolving the contradiction
  4. DSource 3, because its activation-policy finding suggests D.C. and Rialto differed in when officers were required to activate their cameras during encountersCorrect

Why D is right

Source 3's meta-analysis identifies a key moderating variable: department policies about when cameras must be activated. This finding provides a framework for understanding why the D.C. study (Source 1) and the Rialto study (Source 2) produced different results—the departments likely had different activation policies. This contextual variable explains divergent outcomes without discrediting either study.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because officers' self-reported feelings about behavioral change do not explain why measured outcomes differed between two departments; self-reports are about perception, not about the policy variables that might explain different outcomes.
B
Incorrect because the Rialto study's results cannot 'prove' that cameras 'always' work; a single study in one small department does not establish universal effectiveness, and this answer does not explain the divergence with the D.C. findings.
C
Incorrect because larger sample size does not automatically make one study's results more valid than another's; the question asks why results differed, not which study is more reliable.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.