Read the following passage and answer the question.
Frederick Law Olmsted, the designer of Central Park, believed that green spaces were not a luxury for the wealthy but a democratic necessity. He argued that parks should function as a shared civic resource, places where people from different walks of life could walk the same paths, breathe the same air, and experience the same beauty. A century and a half later, his vision has been both vindicated and betrayed. Research consistently shows that access to green space improves physical health, reduces stress, strengthens community bonds, and even lowers crime rates. Olmsted was right about the benefits. But the distribution of those benefits has followed a depressingly familiar pattern. Recent studies have found that parks in neighborhoods with majority nonwhite populations tend to be significantly more crowded and less well-funded than parks in majority-white neighborhoods. Olmsted's egalitarian vision has become another site of inequality — not because the idea was wrong, but because we lacked the political will to fund it equitably.
The author uses the phrase "both vindicated and betrayed" to describe Olmsted's vision because
- AOlmsted's park designs proved aesthetically successful even as they caused unforeseen ecological harm to urban ecosystems
- BCentral Park has been carefully preserved while comparable parks in other major cities have fallen into disrepair
- Cthe health benefits Olmsted predicted have been confirmed, though equitable access to those benefits remains unrealizedCorrect
- Dmodern park users largely prefer athletic facilities and playgrounds to Olmsted's original pastoral, contemplative designs
Why C is right
The passage explains the vindication (research confirms green space benefits health, reduces stress, and lowers crime) and the betrayal (parks in nonwhite neighborhoods are overcrowded and underfunded). Olmsted was right about what parks could do, but his egalitarian vision has not been realized because access is unequal.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage does not discuss the ecological impact of park designs; the vindication and betrayal refer to social equity, not environmental outcomes.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage does not single out Central Park's maintenance; the contrast is between parks in white and nonwhite neighborhoods, not between Central Park and other parks.
- D
- Incorrect because user preferences for park features are not discussed; the passage addresses funding and access disparities, not design preferences.