Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Economic theory

Economic theory appears in 12 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Economic theory is tested

Example 1Harder
Read the following passage. "Let me anticipate the objection: you will say that the free market, left to its own devices, will correct these imbalances. That the invisible hand, which Adam Smith invoked with considerably more nuance than his modern disciples recall, will guide resources to their most efficient allocation. That regulation distorts, intervention corrupts, and the best government is the government that governs least. I have heard these arguments. I find them elegant. I find them internally consistent. And I find them refuted by every textile mill that employed children, every mine that collapsed on its workers, every river that caught fire because no regulation prevented the dumping of industrial waste into waters that the market had efficiently priced at zero." The author's strategy of praising the opponent's arguments as "elegant" and "internally consistent" before listing their empirical failures is best characterized as
  1. Aa genuine concession that undercuts and ultimately weakens the force of the author's own subsequent rebuttal
  2. Ban appeal to authority that invokes Adam Smith's reputation to lend unearned support to the author's position
  3. Csarcasm that disguises contempt as sincere compliment in order to undermine the opposition's credibility
  4. Da strategic acknowledgment of the opposing view's theoretical merit that sharpens the force of the empirical refutationCorrect

Why D is right

By praising the arguments as 'elegant' and 'internally consistent,' the author grants them theoretical legitimacy before demonstrating their empirical failure. This strategic acknowledgment makes the rebuttal more devastating: the arguments are not stupid or incoherent — they are simply wrong in practice, which is a more damaging critique than dismissal.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the concession strengthens rather than weakens the rebuttal by demonstrating intellectual honesty and raising the stakes of the empirical evidence.
B
Incorrect because the author mentions Adam Smith to note that his ideas have been oversimplified by modern advocates, not to invoke his authority in support of the author's own argument.
C
Incorrect because the praise appears genuine rather than sarcastic; the author truly finds the arguments elegant but inadequate, which is a different rhetorical posture than contemptuous mockery.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.