Read the following passage and answer the question.
The phrase 'affordable housing' has been so thoroughly co-opted that it now means its opposite. Developers receive tax credits and zoning variances in exchange for designating a percentage of units as 'affordable' — defined, in most programs, as costing no more than thirty percent of the Area Median Income. But the Area Median Income in Manhattan is $93,000, making an 'affordable' one-bedroom apartment cost roughly $2,325 per month. For a home health aide earning $32,000, or a public school teacher earning $45,000, or a restaurant worker earning $28,000, this 'affordable' apartment is as unaffordable as the market-rate unit next door. The word has been hollowed out, its meaning inverted. 'Affordable' housing is affordable only to those who do not need affordability.
The author's analysis of the term 'affordable housing' exemplifies which rhetorical technique?
- AStatistical analysis comparing housing market trends and price data across several different metropolitan regions
- BAppeal to emotion through vivid personal anecdotes about individuals facing housing insecurity
- CDeconstruction of a term's operational definition to expose the gap between connotation and practiceCorrect
- DAd hominem attack that questions developers' integrity rather than examining the program's actual eligibility rules
Why C is right
The author deconstructs 'affordable housing' by examining how it is operationally defined (30% of Area Median Income), applying that definition to specific income levels, and demonstrating that the term's real-world application contradicts its plain meaning. This is linguistic deconstruction in service of argument.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the analysis focuses on a single term's definition rather than broad cross-regional market trends.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage uses income statistics and definitional critique rather than personal anecdotes.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage critiques the program's definitions and criteria, not individual developers' character or integrity.