Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Credibility

Credibility appears in 7 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Credibility is tested

Example 1Harder
Read the following passage, then answer the question. The editorial board has considered the arguments for and against the proposed stadium and finds them, in the final accounting, almost perfectly balanced. The economic projections submitted by the developer are plausible but not compelling: similar projects in comparable cities have produced returns ranging from spectacular to catastrophic, with the median outcome settling uncomfortably close to break-even. The community opposition is sincere but not unanimous: the petition against the stadium gathered 4,200 signatures, representing 31% of registered voters — a significant minority but a minority nonetheless. The environmental impact assessment identified concerns that are real but mitigable, assuming the mitigation measures are actually funded, which history suggests they may not be. We do not endorse the stadium. We do not oppose it. We recommend that the city council delay the vote until three conditions are met: an independent economic audit, a binding commitment to fund environmental mitigation, and a public referendum that allows all voters, not merely petition signers, to register their position. The passage's organizational structure — presenting balanced assessments of each argument before offering a conditional recommendation — reflects which rhetorical purpose?
  1. ARevealing the editorial board's inability to reach a firm conclusion, since weighing every side equally only postpones any real judgment about the stadium
  2. BUndermining both sides of the debate equally so that no faction can claim victory, implying the stadium question is too contested to ever be resolved
  3. CArguing that the stadium should be approved without delay, since the economic projections and mitigable concerns outweigh the minority opposition
  4. DEstablishing the board's credibility through evenhanded analysis, so the final recommendation feels earned rather than predeterminedCorrect

Why D is right

By presenting each argument with its strengths and limitations (projections 'plausible but not compelling,' opposition 'sincere but not unanimous,' concerns 'real but mitigable'), the editorial board demonstrates fairness and analytical rigor. This balanced structure establishes credibility (ethos), making the conditional recommendation — delay until three conditions are met — feel earned rather than predetermined.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the board does reach a specific recommendation (delay pending three conditions); presenting balanced arguments is a rhetorical strategy that builds toward a conclusion, not evidence that judgment has been postponed.
B
Incorrect because the board does not treat the issue as unresolvable; it specifies exactly what would allow a responsible decision, indicating resolution is achievable with better information.
C
Incorrect because the board explicitly calls for delay, not immediate approval; the balanced assessment supports caution and further verification, not swift construction.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.