Read the following passage.
"The colonizer's map shows a blank space where the forest is. The label reads 'terra nullius' — empty land, land belonging to no one. But the forest is not empty. It contains approximately two thousand people who have lived there for eight hundred years, who have named every river and cataloged every plant, who have developed agricultural techniques adapted precisely to the soil and climate, and who have managed the forest's resources sustainably for longer than the colonizing nation has existed. The map does not show these people because the mapmaker did not ask. The land appears empty because the mapmaker defined 'empty' as 'not occupied by people who resemble me.' Terra nullius is not a geographical fact; it is a political fiction — and the evidence against it is standing on the land, speaking languages the cartographer chose not to learn."
The author refutes the terra nullius doctrine by presenting which type of counter-evidence?
- ATestimony from the colonizer's own historians who later acknowledged the indigenous presence in official records
- BSatellite imagery and modern land surveys showing that the forest is actually cultivated, developed agricultural land
- CLegal precedent from international courts and treaties that have ruled against terra nullius claims in other territories
- DThe documented existence, knowledge, and sustainable practices of the indigenous inhabitants the doctrine ignoredCorrect
Why D is right
The author presents the indigenous inhabitants themselves as counter-evidence: their population (two thousand people), their history (eight hundred years), their knowledge (every river named, every plant cataloged), their technology (adapted agricultural techniques), and their stewardship (sustainable resource management). This evidence directly contradicts the 'empty land' fiction by documenting the comprehensive presence the doctrine denied.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage explicitly notes that the colonizer did not ask or learn about the inhabitants, making colonizer testimony (official or otherwise) unavailable as the cited evidence.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage describes indigenous presence and knowledge directly, not modern satellite or survey verification of land use.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage does not cite legal rulings or treaties; it provides descriptive evidence of indigenous presence, knowledge, and practices instead.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A student is preparing a presentation arguing that electric vehicles (EVs) are not as environmentally beneficial as commonly believed. She has compiled the following sources:
Source 1: A lifecycle analysis published in Nature Energy found that EVs produce 50-70% fewer greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline vehicles over their lifetime, even when accounting for battery manufacturing and electricity generation.
Source 2: A report from the International Energy Agency found that mining lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries has caused significant environmental degradation in the Democratic Republic of Congo, Chile, and Indonesia, including water contamination, deforestation, and displacement of indigenous communities.
Source 3: The U.S. Department of Energy reports that the environmental benefit of EVs varies dramatically by region: in states where electricity comes primarily from coal, EVs may produce only 10-15% fewer emissions than gasoline vehicles, while in states with clean electricity grids, the reduction can exceed 80%.
Source 4: An automotive industry analysis projects that global EV battery demand will require a 40-fold increase in lithium mining by 2040, raising questions about the sustainability of current mining practices at that scale.
Which source most directly undermines the student's thesis?
- ASource 4, because it projects increased demand for lithium mining
- BSource 1, because it demonstrates that EVs produce substantially fewer emissions over their lifetime even accounting for the factors the student's thesis is likely to emphasizeCorrect
- CSource 3, because it shows regional variation in EV benefits
- DSource 2, because it documents environmental harm from battery mining
Why B is right
The student's thesis is that EVs are 'not as environmentally beneficial as commonly believed.' Source 1 directly undermines this by providing lifecycle data showing 50-70% fewer emissions than gasoline vehicles, even after accounting for battery manufacturing and electricity generation—the very factors the student would cite. This source provides the strongest counterevidence to the 'not as beneficial' claim.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Source 4 supports the student's thesis by raising sustainability concerns about scaled-up mining; it strengthens rather than undermines the 'not as beneficial' argument.
- C
- Incorrect because Source 3 partially supports the student's thesis by showing that EV benefits are minimal in coal-dependent regions; while it also shows high benefits in clean-grid regions, it does not as directly counter the overall thesis as Source 1 does.
- D
- Incorrect because Source 2 actually supports the student's thesis by documenting environmental harm from battery mining; it provides evidence for the 'not as beneficial' argument, not against it.