Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Concrete evidence

Concrete evidence appears in 5 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Concrete evidence is tested

Example 1Easier
Read the following passage and answer the question. The urban planning profession has begun to reckon with its own history — specifically, with the role that planning played in enforcing racial segregation. The interstate highway system, celebrated as an engineering marvel, was routed through Black neighborhoods in city after city: Miami's Overtown, Detroit's Black Bottom, Syracuse's 15th Ward, St. Paul's Rondo. These routing decisions were not accidental. They were deliberate choices to demolish communities whose political power was insufficient to resist and whose displacement was, to the white suburban commuters the highways were built to serve, invisible. The planning profession's complicity in this destruction is now well documented, and several cities — Rochester, Syracuse, Duluth — are removing or burying the highways that divided their communities. The question is whether this physical reconstruction will be accompanied by the institutional reconstruction necessary to prevent future harm. The author's list of specific neighborhoods destroyed by highways (Overtown, Black Bottom, 15th Ward, Rondo) serves which purpose?
  1. ATo make the case that every interstate highway built during that era should be torn down as a matter of policy, without exception
  2. BTo lend the passage a poetic quality through evocative, memorable neighborhood names, functioning mainly as emotional decoration rather than as evidence
  3. CTo compare the relative severity of urban planning failures across the specific cities the author names in the passage
  4. DTo make the abstract claim about highway-driven segregation concrete and specific, lending it the weight of documented historyCorrect

Why D is right

Naming specific neighborhoods transforms the abstract claim about highway-driven segregation into concrete, verifiable history. Each name represents a real community that was destroyed, lending the argument the weight of documented fact rather than theoretical assertion.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the passage describes selective highway removal in a few cities, not a blanket argument for demolishing every highway ever built.
B
Incorrect because the named communities are real, documented losses offered as evidence, not decorative or poetic flourishes.
C
Incorrect because the examples illustrate a shared pattern of destruction across cities, not a ranking or comparison of planning quality or severity.
Example 2Medium
Read the following passage. "The hospital was not integrated until 1966 — twelve years after Brown v. Board. For twelve years, Black patients were treated in a separate wing with separate equipment by separate staff. The Black ward had fewer beds, older machines, and no air conditioning. The white ward had a waiting room with magazines and potted plants. The Black ward had plastic chairs bolted to the floor. These details matter. They matter because the argument for segregation was always that separate facilities would be equal, and these details prove they never were. Every plastic chair bolted to a floor while a potted plant graced another waiting room is evidence — small, concrete, irrefutable evidence — that 'separate but equal' was always a lie, and that the lie was so pervasive it extended to the quality of the chair you sat in while you waited to be told whether you would live." The author uses specific physical details (plastic chairs, potted plants) as evidence to
  1. Aevoke a sense of nostalgia for the design conventions of an earlier era in hospital architecture
  2. Bcompare the healthcare quality in segregated hospitals unfavorably to that of today's modern, integrated hospital facilities
  3. Cdemonstrate, through small but concrete details, that the 'separate but equal' doctrine was never actually equal in practiceCorrect
  4. Dargue that hospital administrators should have prioritized visual aesthetics over medical functionality when designing wards

Why C is right

The physical details — plastic chairs vs. potted plants, bolted furniture vs. comfortable waiting rooms — serve as small but irrefutable evidence that 'separate but equal' was a fiction. These tangible disparities prove that the inequality extended to every detail of the patient experience, making the abstract constitutional claim concretely falsifiable through physical observation.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the passage is critical of the era it describes, not nostalgic for it.
B
Incorrect because the passage contrasts the two segregated wards with each other, not with modern hospitals.
D
Incorrect because the details serve to demonstrate inequality, not to argue that hospitals should have prioritized aesthetics.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.