Read the following passage and answer the question.
The United States admits approximately one million legal immigrants per year — a number that has remained remarkably stable since the Immigration Act of 1990. This figure is determined not by labor market analysis, demographic projections, or economic modeling but by a political compromise reached over three decades ago. Canada, by contrast, adjusts its immigration targets annually based on detailed assessments of labor shortages, population growth, and regional needs. Australia uses a points-based system that prioritizes skills, language proficiency, and age. Both countries treat immigration as an economic policy tool, calibrated to national interest. The United States treats it as a political artifact, frozen in the amber of a deal struck when the Soviet Union still existed.
The comparison to Canada and Australia in the passage primarily serves to
- Acriticize all three countries equally for their outdated approaches to setting immigration levels
- Bdemonstrate that evidence-based immigration frameworks exist and operate successfully elsewhereCorrect
- Csuggest that Canada and Australia have eliminated all problems associated with immigration policy
- Dargue that the United States should abandon its 1990 policy and adopt Canada's specific approach
Why B is right
The international comparisons function as existence proofs — they demonstrate that evidence-based, regularly adjusted immigration systems are not merely theoretical but operational in comparable nations. This undermines the implicit assumption that the U.S. system is the only viable model.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage criticizes only the U.S. approach; the Canadian and Australian systems are presented favorably.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage does not claim these countries have perfected immigration policy, only that their approach is more evidence-based.
- D
- Incorrect because the author presents multiple models (Canadian and Australian) without advocating for the wholesale adoption of any single one.