Read the following passage, then answer the question.
Consider Rosa Gutierrez, who crossed the border at nineteen with two hundred dollars and a ninth-grade education. Twenty-three years later, she owns a bakery that employs eleven people, pays $47,000 annually in local taxes, and sponsors a Little League team that has won the regional championship three times. Her story is not unusual. In the border communities of South Texas, immigrant-owned businesses account for 34% of all small business revenue. Rosa's success does not prove that immigration policy should be reformed — no single anecdote carries that weight. But it illustrates a principle that aggregate data confirms: immigrant entrepreneurship generates economic activity that extends far beyond the immigrants themselves. The bakery's flour comes from a mill in Kansas. Its ovens were manufactured in Ohio. Its delivery van was purchased from a dealership in San Antonio. Rosa's American dream is not a solo performance. It is an ensemble production, and the entire cast benefits.
The author acknowledges that 'no single anecdote carries that weight' most likely in order to
- Aacknowledge that anecdotal evidence alone is insufficient, then reinforce the story with statistical supportCorrect
- Bconcede that the case for immigration reform rests on weak evidence that no amount of subsequent statistical support can strengthen
- Ctransition from Rosa's individual experience to a broader legal and legislative discussion of immigration reform policy
- Dundermine Rosa's story by implying that her success is a statistical outlier with no bearing on the wider immigration debate
Why A is right
The acknowledgment functions as a concession that strengthens the argument: by admitting the limitation of anecdotal evidence, the author preempts the counterargument and then immediately supplements the anecdote with aggregate data (34% of small business revenue). This combination of narrative and statistics produces a more persuasive case than either alone.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the author does not concede that the case is weak or unsalvageable; the concession about anecdotal limitations is immediately followed by statistical evidence that confirms and strengthens the argument's central claim.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage does not shift to a legal or legislative discussion; the author moves from anecdote to aggregate economic data, maintaining the focus on entrepreneurship rather than law or policy mechanics.
- D
- Incorrect because the author does not undermine Rosa's story or dismiss it as an outlier; the acknowledgment is followed by supporting data that validates the principle her story illustrates, strengthening rather than weakening the example.