Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Argument analysis

Argument analysis appears in 14 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Argument analysis is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage and answer the question. The appeal of conspiracy theories is often attributed to ignorance, but this explanation is both condescending and inadequate. Conspiracy thinking is not the absence of reasoning but a style of reasoning—one that applies genuine analytical tools (pattern recognition, skepticism of official narratives, attention to detail) to reach unfounded conclusions. The conspiracy theorist who insists that a mass shooting was staged may be factually wrong, but she is not intellectually passive. She has examined evidence, identified apparent inconsistencies, constructed alternative explanations, and defended them against criticism. She has done, in other words, something very close to critical thinking—everything except subjecting her own conclusions to the same scrutiny she applies to official accounts. This observation matters because it changes the prescription. If conspiracy thinking were mere ignorance, education would cure it. But because it is a form of motivated reasoning—reasoning shaped by pre-existing distrust of institutions—the response must address the distrust itself, not merely supply more facts. The author's argument about conspiracy theories relies most heavily on which rhetorical appeal?
  1. ALogos, using logical analysis to redefine the problem and support a different proposed solutionCorrect
  2. BPathos, using emotional stories of conspiracy theorists to generate sympathy for their beliefs
  3. CKairos, arguing that conspiracy theories are a uniquely urgent crisis demanding immediate institutional action
  4. DEthos, establishing the author's credibility as an experienced researcher of conspiracy theories and misinformation

Why A is right

The passage proceeds through logical analysis: it identifies a flawed premise (conspiracy thinking as ignorance), redefines the phenomenon (as motivated reasoning resembling critical thinking except for self-scrutiny), and derives a logical consequence for the solution (address institutional distrust rather than supply facts). Each step builds on the previous one through reasoned argument, making logos the dominant appeal.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because the passage does not use emotional narratives or attempt to generate sympathy; it analyzes conspiracy thinking in detached, analytical terms.
C
Incorrect because the passage does not invoke urgency or timeliness; it offers a reframing of the problem and its solution without suggesting that immediate action is required.
D
Incorrect because the author does not mention personal credentials, experience, or authority; the argument's persuasiveness comes from its logical structure, not the author's identity.
Example 2Harder
Read the following passage and answer the question. The asylum system was designed for a world of discrete political persecutions — a dissident fleeing a dictator, a minority targeted by a pogrom. It was not designed for the mass displacements of the twenty-first century, in which millions flee not a single persecutor but a constellation of overlapping crises: gang violence, state corruption, agricultural collapse driven by climate change, and the generalized breakdown of civic order. The legal categories have not kept pace with the reality. A Honduran farmer whose crops have failed for the third consecutive year due to drought, whose village has been extorted by a gang the police refuse to confront, and whose children face recruitment into narcotrafficking does not fit neatly into the legal definition of a 'refugee.' Yet his need is no less urgent than that of the Cold War dissident for whom the system was built. The author's argument about the asylum system relies primarily on which of the following warrants?
  1. AIndividual nations retain the sole right to decide whether to accept asylum seekers, regardless of international legal obligations.
  2. BThe current international legal framework is broken beyond repair and should be abolished rather than reformed to meet new realities.
  3. CLegal systems should evolve to address changing conditions, even when those conditions differ from what the system was built for.Correct
  4. DEconomic hardship is now a more legitimate basis for asylum than political persecution, since it affects far more displaced people.

Why C is right

The author's unstated but implied warrant is that legal systems should adapt to new realities. The passage argues that the asylum system was appropriate for its historical context but has not evolved to address contemporary forms of displacement, implying that it should.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the passage argues that asylum categories should adapt to modern crises, not that nations may unilaterally disregard obligations to those in need.
B
Incorrect because the author calls for evolution and adaptation of the existing system, not its wholesale abolition.
D
Incorrect because the passage does not rank persecution and economic hardship by legitimacy but argues that modern displacement involves both, requiring updated legal categories.
Example 3Medium
Read the following passage and answer the question. Pandemic preparedness, as practiced by most nations before 2020, was an exercise in confident abstraction. Governments drafted thick binders of response protocols, stockpiled supplies that quietly expired in warehouses, and conducted tabletop exercises in which officials moved color-coded magnets across whiteboards. The plans assumed a cooperative public, a transparent flow of scientific information, and supply chains that would bend but not break. Every one of these assumptions proved catastrophic when tested against reality. The lesson is not that planning is futile—it is that planning which does not account for the irrational, the political, and the logistically impossible is indistinguishable from no planning at all. A blueprint that cannot survive contact with human nature is not a blueprint; it is a wish. Which of the following best describes the logical structure of the author's argument?
  1. AThe author describes a practice, exposes the assumptions that undermined it, and redefines what effective planning requires.Correct
  2. BThe author cites statistical data from past pandemics to project the likely outcome of the next public health emergency.
  3. CThe author weighs two competing pandemic-response strategies and concludes that the more centralized approach is superior.
  4. DThe author opens with a historical analogy about past crises, then narrows to a specific claim that qualifies its lesson.

Why A is right

The passage describes pre-2020 pandemic planning, exposes its flawed assumptions (cooperative public, transparent information, resilient supply chains), and concludes by redefining genuine preparedness as planning that accounts for human irrationality and political realities. There is no statistical evidence (B), no comparison of two competing approaches (C), and no historical analogy followed by a qualified claim (D).
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because the passage relies on descriptive and analytical reasoning, not statistical data, to make its point.
C
Incorrect because the passage critiques a single approach rather than comparing two competing methods.
D
Incorrect because the author opens with a description of an actual practice, not a historical analogy, and moves from critique to redefinition rather than qualification.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.