Should Public Libraries Eliminate Overdue Fines?
Introduction
For more than a century, many public libraries have charged small daily fines when borrowers return materials late, but in recent years some library systems have dropped these fines entirely, while others have kept them. Supporters say fines keep books moving and fund services, while critics say fines push away the readers who most need a library.
Assignment
Read the six sources below, including the introductory note on each. Then write an essay that argues your position on whether public libraries should eliminate overdue fines. Use material from at least three of the sources.
Your essay should: - Take a clear position that a reasonable person could dispute. - Draw evidence from at least three of the sources to build your line of reasoning, and identify each source you use (Source A, Source B, and so on, or by its description). - Explain how your evidence supports your reasoning. - Communicate your argument in clear, correct prose.
Source A (Whitcomb) Source B (Harlow County table) Source C (Prentiss) Source D (Directors survey) Source E (Achterberg) Source F (Okonjo)
Source A Whitcomb, Dana. "The Card in the Drawer." An opinion column by a branch library manager, published in a regional newspaper, 2022.
Behind my circulation desk there used to be a drawer of blocked library cards, because our system blocked any card once its fines reached ten dollars, and most of those cards belonged to children. A third-grader does not lose a book on purpose: her family moves, the book ends up in a box, and the fines pile up at twenty-five cents a day, and then she stops coming. I never saw her parents argue about the fine; I just stopped seeing the family. When our board dropped fines last year, I emptied that drawer, and within a month eleven of those children had checked out books again.
Source B Table adapted from the annual report of the Harlow County Library System, a mid-sized county system, comparing the last full year with fines (2019) to the first full year without them (2021).
Measure | 2019 (fines) | 2021 (no fines) Revenue from overdue fines | $212,000 | $0 Active cardholders | 48,300 | 55,900 Accounts blocked for unpaid fines | 6,100 | 900 Items returned within two weeks of due date | 91% | 88%
Note: All branches were closed from March to June 2020, and returns were paused during that period. Fines for lost or damaged items were kept in 2021.
Source C Prentiss, Gerald. Remarks by a city council member at a public budget hearing, 2023.
I have nothing against kindness, but a due date with no consequence is only a suggestion. Our libraries collected about $140,000 in fines last year. That is not most of the budget, but it is the summer reading program and the weekend hours at two branches. If we drop fines, someone has to tell me which of those we cut, or which tax we raise. I also think a small fine teaches young people something useful, which is that borrowing is a promise.
Source D Summary of a survey of 214 public library directors, conducted by a state library association, 2023.
Of directors whose systems had eliminated daily overdue fines, 71 percent reported that return rates were 'about the same' a year later. Another 18 percent reported a small decline, and 11 percent reported an increase. Most directors said staff spent noticeably less time handling fine disputes at the desk. Several noted that unreturned items were still recovered through other means, such as blocking new checkouts once an item was more than thirty days overdue.
Source E Achterberg, Lena. From a book on the history of American libraries by a librarian and historian, 2020.
The overdue fine is older than the free public library, because it began in subscription libraries, private clubs whose members paid dues to share a collection. In a club, a fine made sense, since it protected the property of paying members from careless ones. When towns began opening free, tax-supported libraries in the mid-1800s, a movement that spread widely by the late 1800s, they copied many club rules, fines included. Few people asked whether a rule built for a members-only club fit an institution that promised to serve everyone.
Source F Okonjo, Adaeze. "I'm Number 43 on the Hold List." A post on a personal blog by a high school junior, 2024.
The new fantasy novel everyone is talking about came out in March, and my library has six copies. I put it on hold, and I am number 43. Here is the thing nobody in the fines debate mentions. When one person keeps a hot new book for an extra month, forty people wait longer. A fine on a 1980s cookbook that no one wants hurts nobody, but I would honestly be fine with a fine on the six copies of that novel.
- (A)Write an essay that develops your position on whether public libraries should eliminate overdue fines. Synthesize material from at least three of the sources above.