Skip to content

Free-response practice

The Synthesis Essay

6 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

The synthesis essay is the first of the three essays in Section II of the AP English Language exam. You get a short introduction to a debatable issue, an assignment, and six or seven sources, and at least one of those sources is visual, such as a table, chart, map, or cartoon. Your job is to take a position on the issue and argue it, using at least three of the sources as evidence.

On this page · 6 sections

Timing: Section II runs 2 hours and 15 minutes for all three essays, and that total includes a 15-minute reading period that is meant for reading the synthesis sources. Plan on about 40 minutes of writing for this essay. Nobody collects it at minute 40, so the discipline of moving on to the next essay is yours.

Points and weight: the essay is scored out of 6, like each of the other two essays, and the three essays together make up 55 percent of your exam score. That makes this one essay worth roughly 18 percent of the whole exam.

How readers score it: high school and college teachers score your essay against an analytic rubric with three rows. Row A, Thesis, is worth 0 or 1; Row B, Evidence and Commentary, is worth 0 to 4; and Row C, Sophistication, is worth 0 or 1. A reader reads the whole essay and then places it in each row. Readers reward what you do well, and they do not take points off for small grammar slips unless the errors get in the way of your meaning.

Row B decides most scores, and it climbs in clear steps. A 1 cites at least two sources but only summarizes them. A 2 cites at least three sources and explains how some of the evidence relates to your argument, but it has no clear line of reasoning, or the reasoning is faulty. So the step from 1 to 2 is the step from summary to commentary. A 3 uses specific evidence to support every claim in a line of reasoning and explains some of that evidence, which means the step from 2 to 3 is building that line of reasoning. A 4 does the same and explains the evidence consistently, all the way through. Two sources keep you at a 1 in Row B, because you need at least three to reach a 2, 3, or 4.

The synthesis essay is not a book report on the sources. Think of the sources as your witnesses and yourself as the lawyer: your argument comes first, and each source appears only when it helps prove a point you are already making.

The rubric, in plain terms

6 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Row A: Thesis1 pt

State a position on the exact question the prompt asks, in a claim someone could reasonably argue against. It can be one or more sentences, anywhere in the essay, though the opening paragraph is safest. It earns nothing if it only restates the prompt, dodges the question, says 'both sides have a point' without choosing, or answers a different question. A thesis that sets up the essay's main reasons in advance is fine but not required.

Row B: Evidence and Commentary4 pts

1 point: draws on at least two sources but only summarizes them, with no explanation of how they support the claim. 2 points: draws on at least three sources and explains how some of the evidence relates to the argument, but no line of reasoning is established or the reasoning is faulty. 3 points: uses specific evidence from at least three sources to support all claims in a line of reasoning, and explains how some of the evidence supports it. 4 points: uses specific evidence from at least three sources to support all claims in a line of reasoning, and consistently explains how the evidence supports it. Grammar or mechanics errors that get in the way of meaning keep an essay from earning the fourth point. Sources must be named (Source A, or the author or title). Misreading a source, or making it say more than it does, weakens the score. (Advice, not a rubric criterion: a strong line of reasoning usually has reasons that build on one another toward the thesis.)

Row C: Sophistication1 pt

Show sophisticated thinking or a complex grasp of the situation, sustained across the essay rather than in one sentence. Common routes: build a nuanced argument that works through real tensions between the sources; place the argument in a wider context and explain what follows from it or where it stops; consistently make rhetorical choices that strengthen the argument's force and impact; or write in a style that is consistently vivid and persuasive. Any one route can earn the point. A flashy opening line or a vague 'this is a complex issue' does not earn it.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

Should Public Libraries Eliminate Overdue Fines?

Introduction

For more than a century, many public libraries have charged small daily fines when borrowers return materials late, but in recent years some library systems have dropped these fines entirely, while others have kept them. Supporters say fines keep books moving and fund services, while critics say fines push away the readers who most need a library.

Assignment

Read the six sources below, including the introductory note on each. Then write an essay that argues your position on whether public libraries should eliminate overdue fines. Use material from at least three of the sources.

Your essay should: - Take a clear position that a reasonable person could dispute. - Draw evidence from at least three of the sources to build your line of reasoning, and identify each source you use (Source A, Source B, and so on, or by its description). - Explain how your evidence supports your reasoning. - Communicate your argument in clear, correct prose.

Source A (Whitcomb) Source B (Harlow County table) Source C (Prentiss) Source D (Directors survey) Source E (Achterberg) Source F (Okonjo)

Source A Whitcomb, Dana. "The Card in the Drawer." An opinion column by a branch library manager, published in a regional newspaper, 2022.

Behind my circulation desk there used to be a drawer of blocked library cards, because our system blocked any card once its fines reached ten dollars, and most of those cards belonged to children. A third-grader does not lose a book on purpose: her family moves, the book ends up in a box, and the fines pile up at twenty-five cents a day, and then she stops coming. I never saw her parents argue about the fine; I just stopped seeing the family. When our board dropped fines last year, I emptied that drawer, and within a month eleven of those children had checked out books again.

Source B Table adapted from the annual report of the Harlow County Library System, a mid-sized county system, comparing the last full year with fines (2019) to the first full year without them (2021).

Measure | 2019 (fines) | 2021 (no fines) Revenue from overdue fines | $212,000 | $0 Active cardholders | 48,300 | 55,900 Accounts blocked for unpaid fines | 6,100 | 900 Items returned within two weeks of due date | 91% | 88%

Note: All branches were closed from March to June 2020, and returns were paused during that period. Fines for lost or damaged items were kept in 2021.

Source C Prentiss, Gerald. Remarks by a city council member at a public budget hearing, 2023.

I have nothing against kindness, but a due date with no consequence is only a suggestion. Our libraries collected about $140,000 in fines last year. That is not most of the budget, but it is the summer reading program and the weekend hours at two branches. If we drop fines, someone has to tell me which of those we cut, or which tax we raise. I also think a small fine teaches young people something useful, which is that borrowing is a promise.

Source D Summary of a survey of 214 public library directors, conducted by a state library association, 2023.

Of directors whose systems had eliminated daily overdue fines, 71 percent reported that return rates were 'about the same' a year later. Another 18 percent reported a small decline, and 11 percent reported an increase. Most directors said staff spent noticeably less time handling fine disputes at the desk. Several noted that unreturned items were still recovered through other means, such as blocking new checkouts once an item was more than thirty days overdue.

Source E Achterberg, Lena. From a book on the history of American libraries by a librarian and historian, 2020.

The overdue fine is older than the free public library, because it began in subscription libraries, private clubs whose members paid dues to share a collection. In a club, a fine made sense, since it protected the property of paying members from careless ones. When towns began opening free, tax-supported libraries in the mid-1800s, a movement that spread widely by the late 1800s, they copied many club rules, fines included. Few people asked whether a rule built for a members-only club fit an institution that promised to serve everyone.

Source F Okonjo, Adaeze. "I'm Number 43 on the Hold List." A post on a personal blog by a high school junior, 2024.

The new fantasy novel everyone is talking about came out in March, and my library has six copies. I put it on hold, and I am number 43. Here is the thing nobody in the fines debate mentions. When one person keeps a hot new book for an extra month, forty people wait longer. A fine on a 1980s cookbook that no one wants hurts nobody, but I would honestly be fine with a fine on the six copies of that novel.

  1. (A)Write an essay that develops your position on whether public libraries should eliminate overdue fines. Synthesize material from at least three of the sources above.
Prompt 2

Should High Schools Require a Personal Finance Course?

Introduction

A growing number of states now require high school students to pass a semester-long personal finance course in order to graduate. The courses usually cover budgeting, credit, loans, taxes, and saving. Supporters say young adults face serious money decisions with no training, while critics question whether a single course changes adult behavior, and what it pushes out of the schedule.

Assignment

Read the six sources below, including the introductory note on each. Then write an essay that argues your position on whether states should require a semester of personal finance for high school graduation. Use material from at least three of the sources.

Your essay should: - Take a clear position that a reasonable person could dispute. - Draw evidence from at least three of the sources to build your line of reasoning, and identify each source you use (Source A, Source B, and so on, or by its description). - Explain how your evidence supports your reasoning. - Communicate your argument in clear, correct prose.

Source A (Lindqvist) Source B (Graduate survey table) Source C (Okafor) Source D (Alvarez) Source E (Student interview) Source F (Brandt)

Source A Lindqvist, Teresa. "They Sign Contracts Before They Can Vote." An opinion column by a high school economics teacher, published in a local newspaper, 2024.

My seniors sign phone contracts, car loans, and their first apartment leases within a year or two of leaving my room. Most have never seen how interest piles up. Last spring, a student worked out the yearly rate on a payday loan advertised near our school, and it came to almost 400 percent. The room went quiet, because nobody had ever shown them that math. A required course means every student sees it, not just the ones whose parents already talk about money at dinner.

Source B Table adapted from a state education department's follow-up survey of 2,400 graduates, five years after high school. The course became a graduation requirement in 2017.

Measure | Graduated 2013-2016 (no requirement) | Graduated 2018-2019 (required course) Have at least $500 in emergency savings | 34% | 41% Missed a credit card payment in the past year | 24% | 18% Rate their own money skills as 'strong' | 31% | 52% Answered three basic finance questions correctly | 39% | 46%

Note: The two groups entered the job market in different years, under different economic conditions.

Source C Okafor, Paul. From an essay by an economist who studies household decisions, published in a policy magazine, 2023.

Classroom finance lessons are not useless, but they fade, and several studies find that what students learn at sixteen is largely gone a few years later, unless they use it. Lessons work best 'just in time,' right before a real decision, such as a short session when someone takes out a student loan. Design choices also matter. Enrolling new workers in a retirement plan automatically raises savings far more than teaching them why saving matters. A semester course can be a good start, but we should not expect it to carry someone through forty years.

Source D Alvarez, Renata. From an interview with a high school counselor, published in an education trade journal, 2024.

A schedule is a fixed number of seats, so when the state adds a required semester, something else has to go, and it is almost always an elective. For my students, that means a semester of art, band, or a second year of Spanish. Students on a tight path, like those in a career program, feel it most. I am not against the course; I just want people to admit it has a cost.

Source E From an interview with a 17-year-old student, published in a high school newspaper, 2024.

Honestly, I thought the class would be boring, but the most useful part was reading a pay stub. I had no idea why my first check from the grocery store was smaller than I expected, and now I know what every line means. I do wish we had spent more time on student loans, since that is the biggest money decision most of us will make next year, and we did only one week on it.

Source F Brandt, Miriam. From a commentary by a sociologist who studies household debt, 2022.

When families fall into money trouble, the usual cause is not a lack of knowledge but a lost job, a medical bill, or wages that do not cover rent. Teaching budgeting to a family that earns too little to budget is like teaching swimming to someone in a flood. Financial education has value, but when lawmakers present it as the answer to household debt, they quietly move the blame from wages and prices onto individuals.

  1. (A)Write an essay that develops your position on whether states should require high school students to complete a semester-long personal finance course in order to graduate. Synthesize material from at least three of the sources above.

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

Should Public Libraries Eliminate Overdue Fines? · high-scoring response6/6

Libraries exist to put books in people's hands, and a fine that keeps a ten-year-old away from the shelves works against that purpose. Public libraries should drop daily overdue fines, but the case is not as simple as "fines are bad." A library without fines still needs a way to get its most wanted books back, and the strongest version of the policy keeps that tool.

The first problem with fines is who actually pays them. Dana Whitcomb, a branch manager, describes a drawer full of cards blocked at ten dollars, most of them belonging to children (Source A). For a family with money, ten dollars is a nuisance, but for a family without it, it is a locked door. The fine is supposed to teach responsibility, yet what it actually teaches a third-grader is that the library is not for her. That is a strange lesson for a public institution to teach.

The numbers from Harlow County back this up (Source B). After the county dropped fines, active cardholders rose from 48,300 to 55,900, and blocked accounts fell from 6,100 to 900. Those 5,200 unblocked accounts are people, not pennies. Councilmember Prentiss is right that fines pay for real things like summer reading (Source C). But Harlow gave up $212,000 while its active cardholders grew by over 7,000. Not all of that growth can be credited to the policy, since the 2020 closure discussed below fell between the two years, but the 5,200 fewer blocked accounts follow directly from ending fines. If a library measures success by who walks in, that trade is worth it. If it measures success by revenue, it has forgotten what it is for.

The obvious objection is that without fines, nobody will bring books back, but the evidence says otherwise. In Harlow, returns within two weeks of the due date dipped only from 91 to 88 percent (Source B). In a survey of directors, 71 percent said returns stayed about the same after fines ended (Source D). The 2020 closure also fell between the two years Harlow compares. Every branch shut for months and returns were paused, so 2021 return habits may have shifted for reasons that have nothing to do with fines. Even that small dip may not come from the policy at all.

Still, the worry is not empty. Adaeze Okonjo, a high school junior, is number 43 on the hold list for a new novel (Source F). When one person keeps that book an extra month, forty people wait. A fine on an old cookbook hurts only the borrower, while a missing bestseller hurts everyone in line. So the best policy is not "no consequences" but the right consequence in the right place. Several directors already block new checkouts once an item is thirty days late (Source D). That puts pressure where it matters without charging a child by the day.

Lena Achterberg points out that fines came from private subscription libraries, which were clubs for paying members (Source E), and free public libraries copied the rule without asking whether it fit. Keeping daily fines keeps a habit from the club era. Dropping them, while protecting high-demand books, finally lets library policy match the promise that the library is for everyone.

How it scored

1/1thesis — The opening paragraph takes a clear, arguable position (drop daily fines) and qualifies it in a way that previews the essay's later move. It answers the question asked rather than restating it.
4/4evidence-commentary — Uses specific evidence from all six sources, and every piece is followed by explanation of what it proves. The line of reasoning builds: who pays fines, what dropping them gained, the return-rate objection, the hold-list exception, and the historical frame. It handles Source C fairly instead of distorting it, and it notices the 2020 closure note in Source B, applying it to both the cardholder and return-rate numbers.
1/1sophistication — Sustained nuance. The writer turns Source F's complication into a refined position (target high-demand items instead of fining everything), and uses Source E to place the debate in a wider historical context. The 'people, not pennies' framing is controlled, not decorative.
Should Public Libraries Eliminate Overdue Fines? · mid-scoring response3/6

Libraries have been an important part of society for thousands of years. Today many people are debating whether libraries should keep overdue fines. Libraries should get rid of overdue fines because they are unfair to poor people, they do not bring in much money, and people return their books anyway.

First, fines are unfair to poor people. In Source A, Dana Whitcomb says that the library blocked cards when kids owed ten dollars. She says a third-grader does not lose a book on purpose. When the fines were dropped, eleven of the children came back. This shows that fines are unfair.

Second, fines do not bring in much money. Councilmember Gerald Prentiss says in Source C that fines are "not most of the budget." Even the people who support fines admit they are not important for the library. The library could easily get the money somewhere else. So there is no reason to keep them.

Third, people return their books anyway. Source B shows a table from Harlow County. In 2019 there were fines and in 2021 there were no fines. Returns went from 91% to 88%. Active cardholders went from 48,300 to 55,900. This proves that getting rid of fines does not cause people to keep books. Source D also says that 71 percent of directors said returns were about the same.

Some people might say that fines teach responsibility. However, the evidence shows that most people return their books anyway, so this is not a good argument.

In the end, libraries should get rid of overdue fines. They are unfair to poor people, they do not make much money, and people return books without them. Libraries are for everyone and fines go against that.

How it scored

1/1thesis — The last sentence of the first paragraph takes a defensible position and lists reasons. The opening sentence about 'thousands of years' adds nothing, but it does not cost the point.
2/4evidence-commentary — Uses four sources, so it clears the three-source bar, but mostly retells them. Each paragraph ends with a restatement ('This shows that fines are unfair') instead of explaining why. It also overstates Source C: Prentiss says fines are not most of the budget but pay for summer reading and weekend hours, which is the opposite of admitting they are unimportant. It reads Source B as 'proof' and ignores the 2020 closure note.
0/1sophistication — The counterargument gets one sentence and is dismissed without engaging Source F's hold-list point or Prentiss's budget trade-off. The sweeping opening line is a gesture, not sophistication.
Should High Schools Require a Personal Finance Course? · high-scoring response5/6

Most eighteen-year-olds will sign a lease, a loan, or a phone contract before anyone has shown them how interest works. States should require a semester of personal finance for graduation, because it is the only way to guarantee that every student, not just the lucky ones, sees that math before it costs them.

The strongest reason is fairness. Teresa Lindqvist, an economics teacher, notes that some students already hear about money at the dinner table (Source A). Those students arrive knowing what an APR is, while everyone else learns it the hard way. When her class worked out that a payday loan near the school charged almost 400 percent a year, the room went silent, and that silence is the point. A student who has done that calculation once is far less likely to walk into that store. An elective cannot reach the students who most need it, because they are the least likely to sign up.

The survey is consistent with the course changing behavior, not just knowledge. In one state's follow-up survey, graduates who took the required course were more likely to have $500 in emergency savings, 41 percent compared with 34 percent (Source B). They were also less likely to miss a credit card payment, 18 percent compared with 24 percent. The survey's note warns that the two groups entered the job market in different years, so the course cannot take all the credit. A better economy could explain more savings and fewer missed payments, but it is a less obvious explanation for why more of the later group answered three basic finance questions correctly, 46 percent compared with 39 percent. The two groups still differ in other ways, but that knowledge gap is the row most plausibly linked to the classroom. And if the course accounts for even part of the drop in missed payments, that matters, because a missed payment can raise someone's interest rates for years.

The course also answers questions students did not know they had. One seventeen-year-old says the most useful lesson was reading a pay stub (Source E). The student had been confused about why that first grocery store check was smaller than expected, and now the student understands taxes and deductions. That is exactly the kind of practical skill a school should guarantee, because it turns a confusing moment into one the student controls.

Critics like counselor Renata Alvarez worry that the course pushes out electives like art or band (Source D). That is a real cost, but a semester of art can be taken later in life for fun. A bad loan at nineteen can follow someone for a decade. When a schedule forces a choice, the class that prevents lasting harm should win.

A required course will not solve every money problem, but it will make sure that no student signs their first contract without understanding it. That is a promise every state should make.

How it scored

1/1thesis — Clear, arguable position on the exact question, with a reason built in (guaranteeing access for every student).
4/4evidence-commentary — Specific evidence from four sources, each one explained. The commentary does real work: why an elective misses the students who need it most, why a lower missed-payment rate matters in dollars, and why the pay stub example is a practical skill. It handles Source B's job-market note honestly: it concedes that the economy could explain the savings and payment gaps, then rests its point on the knowledge row, which a different economy is a less obvious way to explain. It also admits the two groups still differ in other ways, so it treats that row as the strongest evidence, not as proof. The reasoning moves from fairness to behavior to everyday use.
0/1sophistication — Not sustained. The writer handles Source B's job-market note in a few sentences and moves on instead of exploring it. The essay also skips Source C (lessons fade) and Source F (money trouble is often about wages, not knowledge), the two sources that most complicate the claim. The Source D rebuttal is sharp but brief, and the last paragraph's nod to limits is one sentence.
Should High Schools Require a Personal Finance Course? · mid-scoring response3/6

Money is a very important part of life. Everyone has to deal with money at some point. Because of this, states should require students to take a personal finance class to graduate high school.

Source A is written by Teresa Lindqvist, who is an economics teacher. She says that her students sign phone contracts and car loans soon after high school. She says a payday loan near her school was almost 400 percent. She thinks every student should take a finance course. I agree with her because students need to know about money.

Source B is a table about graduates. It shows that people who took the course had more savings (41% vs 34%) and missed fewer payments (18% vs 24%). They also rated their money skills as strong more often. This proves that the class works and makes people better with money.

Source C is by an economist named Paul Okafor. He says that finance classes do not work because students forget what they learned. He thinks schools should not teach finance and should just enroll people in retirement plans automatically. I disagree with him because if students forget, the teachers should just teach it better.

Source E is an interview with a student. The student said reading a pay stub was useful and also wanted more time on student loans. This shows that students find the class helpful.

In conclusion, states should require personal finance classes. The sources show that the class helps students learn about money and make better choices. Even though some people disagree, the class is worth it.

How it scored

1/1thesis — The third sentence takes a defensible position on the question, even though the two sentences before it are filler.
2/4evidence-commentary — Four sources are cited, but the essay is organized source by source, so it reads as a tour of the packet instead of a line of reasoning. Commentary is mostly 'I agree' or 'this proves.' It misreads Source C: Okafor says lessons fade and work best just in time, and calls a semester course 'a good start.' He does not say schools should stop teaching finance. It also treats Source B as proof and ignores the note about different job markets.
0/1sophistication — The one counterargument is a misread version of Source C, answered with 'teach it better.' The tensions raised by Sources D and F are ignored. The broad opening about money being important does not earn the point.

Where points die

Walking through the sources one at a time: a paragraph on Source A, then one on Source B, then one on Source C. Organize by your reasons, not by the packet. Each body paragraph should open with a claim of your own, and then pull in whichever sources prove it, often two in the same paragraph. Readers see the source-by-source essay as summary, and pure summary earns a 1 in Row B. A few explanations without a line of reasoning top out at 2, so to reach 3, the reasoning has to run through your own claims.

Making a source say more than it does. A writer who says fines are 'not most of the budget' gets reported as saying fines don't matter. An economist who says lessons fade gets reported as saying schools should not teach finance. Before you cite a source, ask what the author actually claims and how far the claim goes, because most authors take a limited position, such as 'this has a cost' or 'this is not enough alone.' Quote or paraphrase that exact claim, since a source misread to fit your thesis costs credibility in Row B.

Misjudging how much a source argues. A blog that reports a complaint is not automatically endorsing it. A historian who mostly reports facts may still slip in a judgment. Separate what the source reports from what its author argues. Achterberg mostly gives history: fines began in private subscription clubs and were copied by free libraries. But her last sentence implies that a club-era rule may not fit a library meant to serve everyone. Cite her for the history, and represent that implication accurately. Do not call her neutral, and do not claim she demands an end to fines.

Dropping in a statistic or quotation and following it with 'This shows that…' plus a restatement of the thesis. After every piece of evidence, explain the link by asking why the number matters, who it affects, and what would be true if it were different. For example, blocked accounts in Harlow fell by 5,200, so 5,200 fewer people were barred from borrowing. Whether those people actually came back is a separate claim the table does not show. Explaining exactly what the number proves, and no more, is the commentary readers reward.

Treating a table or chart as unquestionable proof and skipping its note. Read the fine print on every visual source, because notes about closures, different time periods, or different groups are put there on purpose. Mentioning that limitation and explaining why your point still holds strengthens your Row B commentary. It can feed the sophistication point only as part of a sustained treatment of tensions and limits across the whole essay, so one sentence about a chart's note will not earn Row C on its own.

Chasing the sophistication point with a grand opening ('Since the dawn of time…') or a final line saying the issue is complex. Sophistication has to run through the argument. Pick the source that most complicates your position, work through it in its own paragraph, and then adjust your claim because of it, as in 'drop daily fines, but protect high-demand books.' That sustained nuance is what readers reward.

Score your own response

0 / 6

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.