Skip to content

Free-response practice

The Rhetorical Analysis Essay

6 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

Question 2 of the AP English Language free-response section hands you a short nonfiction passage — a speech, a letter, an essay, an article — and asks how the writer builds it. Your job is not to judge whether the argument is right. Your job is to explain what the writer does, and why it works on that audience, in that moment. You will write three essays in 2 hours and 15 minutes: synthesis, rhetorical analysis, and argument. Each is worth 6 points, and together they are 55 percent of your exam score. Budget about 45 minutes here: 8 to 10 minutes reading and annotating, the rest writing. Readers score your essay in seconds per page against three rows. Row A is the thesis, worth 1 point. Row B is evidence and commentary, worth 4 — this row decides your score. Row C is sophistication, worth 1, and it is rare. Readers reward one thing above everything else: a chain of reasoning that connects a specific choice in the text to a specific effect on the audience. 'The writer uses pathos' earns nothing. 'By naming the laid-off millworker teaching himself to write a job application, Marsh forces the council to picture exactly whose access it is voting away' earns points. Analyze choices, not devices. Name the audience. Explain the work each choice does.

On this page · 6 sections

The rubric, in plain terms

6 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Thesis (Row A)1 pt

Make a defensible claim about the writer's rhetorical choices and what they accomplish. One clear sentence anywhere in the essay can earn it. You lose this point by restating the prompt, listing devices with no claim attached, or summarizing what the passage says instead of what it does.

Evidence and Commentary (Row B)4 pts

This row is a ladder. 1 point: evidence is present but mostly summary, barely tied to any claim. 2 points: relevant quotes, but the commentary asserts vague effects — 'this engages the reader,' 'this builds credibility' — without explaining how. 3 points: specific evidence with commentary that explains how most choices work, but the reasoning breaks down in places or some evidence sits unexplained. 4 points: specific evidence throughout, and every piece of commentary explains how that choice moves that audience toward the writer's purpose, in one consistent line of reasoning.

Sophistication (Row C)1 pt

Show real rhetorical insight and sustain it: situate the passage in the pressures of its moment, trace how choices build on each other or shift across the text, or account for tensions and complexities in the argument. Big vocabulary, a flowery conclusion, or one clever sentence does not earn it. A whole essay written at a higher level of thinking does.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

The Librarian's Letter

The following letter was written in March 1970 by Helen Marsh, head librarian of the public library in the fictional mill town of Harlan Falls, Ohio. The town council had proposed cutting the library's budget by ending evening and Saturday hours.

To the members of the Harlan Falls Town Council:

I have been the librarian of this town for twenty-two years. In that time I have learned the names of three generations of readers. I checked out Charlotte's Web to children who now bring me their own children on Saturday mornings. So I ask you to hear me not as a department head defending a budget line, but as a witness testifying to what that line buys.

You have called the library a luxury. I want to examine that word. A luxury is a thing we enjoy but could do without. Last winter, Mr. Kowalski, who lost his job when the mill cut its second shift, sat at our reading table every morning with the classified pages and a borrowed dictionary, teaching himself to write a letter of application. Was that a luxury? The Hendricks girl, who has no encyclopedia at home, has written every school report of her life at our corner table. Was that? The men who come in to read the Cleveland papers because a subscription costs more than they can spare — are they enjoying a luxury, or exercising a right?

The proposal before you would save the town four thousand dollars by closing our doors on evenings and Saturdays. But hours are not trimmings. Evenings and Saturdays are the only hours a working man has. Cut them, and you have not shortened the library. You have closed it to everyone whose labor pays for it, and kept it open for those who need it least.

I know the arguments of necessity. The budget must balance. Cuts must fall somewhere. But a budget is not weather. It does not simply happen to us. It is a list of what we have decided to care about, written in numbers. I ask the council to look at that list and say plainly: we have decided that the reading of our neighbors is what we care about least.

If you make that decision, make it with open eyes. Do not call the library a luxury so that the decision feels easier. The word does not make it true; it only makes it quiet.

Respectfully, Helen Marsh

  1. (1)Read the passage carefully. Write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Marsh makes to convey her message to the town council. In your response: state a defensible thesis about Marsh's rhetorical choices; support it with specific evidence from the letter; explain how each choice you discuss helps Marsh achieve her purpose with this audience; and show that you understand the rhetorical situation — who is writing, to whom, and under what pressure.
Prompt 2

The Country Doctor's Address

The following is an excerpt from an address delivered in May 1988 by Dr. Alma Reyes, a fictional physician who practiced for thirty years in rural New Mexico, to the graduating class of a state university medical school.

Members of the graduating class: you have been told, correctly, that you are entering the most powerful profession on earth. I want to talk about where you will point that power.

Thirty years ago I stood where you stand. I was offered a residency at a famous hospital in a famous city, and I turned it down for a town of nine hundred people at the end of a two-lane road. My professors told me I was wasting my training. Let me tell you what I wasted it on.

I wasted it on Delia Ortiz, who was born in my clinic at two in the morning and who is now, I am told, studying chemistry. I wasted it on the ranch hands whose hands I stitched, the miners whose lungs I listened to, the grandmothers who did not have to ride four hours on a bus to be told their pain was treatable. In thirty years I have delivered six hundred babies and driven eleven thousand miles a year doing it. That is what waste looks like where I live.

Here is the arithmetic nobody printed in your acceptance letters. In this state there is one doctor for every three hundred people in the cities, and one for every three thousand in the counties without a stoplight. Illness does not distribute itself this way. Only doctors do.

I am not asking all of you to follow me. Cities need surgeons; research needs minds; I read the journals your future colleagues will write, and I use what they discover. But some of you — and you already suspect who you are — will feel the pull of the places nobody is. I am here to tell you that the pull is trustworthy. Prestige is a spotlight: it shows you to others. Usefulness is a lamp: it shows you the work. You can only carry one of them down a dirt road at midnight.

When they hand you your diploma this afternoon, it will not say where to go. It never does. That page you have to write yourself.

  1. (1)Read the passage carefully. Write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Reyes makes to achieve her purpose of persuading new physicians to consider practicing where doctors are scarce. In your response: state a defensible thesis about Reyes's rhetorical choices; support it with specific evidence from the speech; explain how each choice you discuss works on this particular audience of ambitious new graduates; and show that you understand the rhetorical situation.

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

The Librarian's Letter · high-scoring response6/6

In March 1970, a town council staring at a budget shortfall could easily see a small library as the softest place to cut. Helen Marsh's letter is built to make that cut hard. Writing as the town's librarian of twenty-two years, she takes the council's own word — "luxury" — and dismantles it with the lives of the people the library serves. Through her framing of herself as a witness rather than an interested employee, her interrogation of the word "luxury" through specific working-class patrons, and her redefinition of the budget itself as a moral document, Marsh transforms a routine spending question into a public test of what the town owes the people whose labor funds it.

Marsh opens by converting her job title into a rhetorical position. She asks to be heard "not as a department head defending a budget line, but as a witness testifying to what that line buys." The distinction is strategic: a department head has an interest, but a witness has knowledge. Her memory of checking out Charlotte's Web to children "who now bring me their own children" turns twenty-two years of employment into twenty-two years of observation, so the specific stories that follow arrive with the weight of evidence rather than sentiment. A council can discount an employee protecting her own budget. It is much harder to discount testimony.

The center of the letter is a definition argument. Rather than protesting the label "luxury," Marsh accepts it long enough to examine it — "a thing we enjoy but could do without" — and then holds the definition against three patrons in turn: Mr. Kowalski teaching himself to write a job application after the mill cut his shift, the Hendricks girl with no encyclopedia at home, the men who cannot afford a newspaper subscription. After each, she asks a version of the same question: "Was that a luxury?" The repeated rhetorical question performs an accusation without the tone of one; each council member must answer silently, and each honest answer erodes the word the proposed cut depends on. Her examples are working-class by design. That selection sets up her sharpest claim — that cutting evenings and Saturdays closes the library "to everyone whose labor pays for it" while keeping it open "for those who need it least" — and quietly reminds elected officials which voters they would be shutting out.

Marsh's most forceful move is her attack on the language of necessity. She concedes the council's arguments in their own agentless, impersonal grammar — "The budget must balance. Cuts must fall somewhere" — and then strips that grammar away: "a budget is not weather. It does not simply happen to us." By redefining the budget as "a list of what we have decided to care about, written in numbers," she removes the council's ability to present the cut as inevitable. Her closing demand, that the council say "plainly" that its neighbors' reading is what it cares about least, forces the decision back into the active voice, where someone must own it. The final line — "The word does not make it true; it only makes it quiet" — compresses the whole letter into a single claim: the council's euphemism is not analysis but anesthesia.

Marsh never asks for sympathy for herself or for the library as an institution. Instead she scripts the confession the council would have to make to proceed. A council could survive trimming a budget line. It could not easily survive announcing that it cares least about the reading of the people whose work pays for the town — and that is exactly the sentence Marsh's letter writes for them.

How it scored

1/1A — The thesis is defensible and specific: it names three choices (witness framing, definition-by-example, redefining the budget as a moral document) and claims what they accomplish — turning a spending question into a test of obligation. It goes well beyond restating the prompt.
4/4B — Evidence is specific and quoted throughout, and every quotation gets commentary that explains its work on this audience: why 'witness' beats 'department head,' what the repeated question forces each council member to do, why the working-class examples matter to elected officials. The line of reasoning is consistent from thesis to conclusion.
1/1C — The essay sustains insight into the rhetorical situation — a 1970 mill town, officials answerable to working voters — and traces how the choices build on each other, ending with the observation that Marsh scripts the council's own confession. That is analysis of strategy, not a list of techniques.
The Librarian's Letter · mid-scoring response3/6

In her letter to the Harlan Falls Town Council, Helen Marsh uses ethos, emotional stories, and rhetorical questions to convince the council not to cut the library's budget.

First, Marsh uses ethos by explaining that she has been the librarian for twenty-two years. She says she checked out Charlotte's Web to children who now bring in their own children. This shows that she is experienced and credible, which makes the audience trust what she says about the library.

Marsh also uses pathos by telling emotional stories about people in the town. Mr. Kowalski lost his job at the mill and used the library every morning to learn how to write a job application. The Hendricks girl does not have an encyclopedia at home, so she does all her school reports at the library. These stories make the council feel sympathy for the people who use the library, and that makes them not want to cut its hours.

Another device Marsh uses is rhetorical questions. She asks "Was that a luxury?" multiple times after her stories. Rhetorical questions make the reader stop and think about the answer, which gets the audience more engaged with her argument.

Marsh also talks about the budget at the end of the letter. She says a budget "is not weather" and calls it "a list of what we have decided to care about, written in numbers." This is a metaphor. It shows the council that the cut is a choice they are making, which supports her argument that they should choose the library.

Overall, Marsh's use of ethos, pathos, and rhetorical questions makes her letter persuasive and shows the council that the library is important to the town and should keep its funding.

How it scored

1/1A — The thesis earns the point, barely: it is defensible and names choices tied to a purpose. But it is a formula — three labeled devices plus 'to convince' — and it previews no actual argument about how the letter works, which caps what the body can deliver.
2/4B — Evidence is relevant and drawn from across the letter, but the commentary asserts generic effects instead of explaining mechanisms: 'makes the audience trust her,' 'makes them feel sympathy,' 'gets the audience more engaged.' Those sentences could describe any text. The essay never says why witness framing matters to a council, why the examples are working people, or what the budget redefinition takes away from the council. Naming 'ethos,' 'pathos,' and 'metaphor' does no analytical work by itself.
0/1C — No sophistication point. The essay treats the letter as a checklist of devices rather than a strategy aimed at elected officials in a mill town, and the choices are discussed in isolation rather than as a building argument.
The Country Doctor's Address · high-scoring response6/6

A commencement audience at a medical school in 1988 has spent a decade being ranked, and it measures success the way its professors do: famous hospitals, famous cities. Alma Reyes cannot persuade these graduates toward rural practice by asking them to want less. So she does something shrewder — she keeps their ambition and redirects it. Through her ironic reclamation of the word "waste," her conversion of statistics into an accusation of choice, and a closing antithesis that redefines prestige itself as the weaker light, Reyes reframes rural medicine not as sacrifice but as the fuller use of the power she says her audience now holds.

Reyes's first move is to seize the strongest word her opponents ever used against her. Her professors said she was "wasting" her training, and instead of rebutting them she adopts the word as a refrain: "I wasted it on Delia Ortiz... I wasted it on the ranch hands whose hands I stitched." Each repetition fills "waste" with a name, a body, a life changed, so the word collapses under its own contents. By the time she declares "That is what waste looks like where I live," the irony has done what a direct rebuttal could not: it lets the graduates keep respecting her professors' standards while watching those standards fail to describe reality. The concrete tally — six hundred babies, eleven thousand miles a year — matters here, because it answers ambition in ambition's own currency: numbers, output, endurance.

Her statistics work the same inversion. The figures — one doctor per three hundred people in the cities, one per three thousand in counties "without a stoplight" — could sit inertly as background data. Reyes weaponizes them with two short sentences: "Illness does not distribute itself this way. Only doctors do." The blunt pairing converts a statistic about scarcity into a statement about agency. The maldistribution is not a natural fact, like climate; it is the sum of career decisions made by people exactly like the ones in front of her. Without ever scolding, she makes each graduate's upcoming choice of residency part of the arithmetic.

What keeps this from feeling like an attack is her deliberate concession. "I am not asking all of you to follow me," she says, granting that "cities need surgeons" and that she depends on the research her urban colleagues produce. The concession protects her from the easy dismissal — that she is romanticizing hardship or condemning ambition — and it narrows her true audience to "some of you — and you already suspect who you are." That sentence recruits by recognition rather than pressure: she is not converting anyone, only confirming a pull some listeners already feel and calling it "trustworthy."

The speech closes by making the choice unavoidable. The spotlight-and-lamp antithesis gives the graduates a clean pair of definitions — prestige "shows you to others," usefulness "shows you the work" — and the image of carrying only one "down a dirt road at midnight" forces the two apart; no one gets both. Then the diploma that "will not say where to go" hands the pen back to the audience. Reyes never tells the graduates what to write on that page. She has only made sure that whichever word they choose, they now know it is a choice — which is, for an audience trained to believe its path was already ranked and set, the most subversive claim in the speech.

How it scored

1/1A — Defensible, specific thesis: it identifies the audience's values, names three choices, and claims a unifying strategy — redirecting ambition rather than opposing it. It sets up a genuine line of reasoning.
4/4B — Every paragraph pairs specific quoted evidence with commentary that explains the mechanism: how repetition empties and refills 'waste,' how two short sentences turn scarcity data into agency, what the concession protects against and whom it targets, why the antithesis forces a choice. Nothing is quoted without being put to work.
1/1C — Sophistication is sustained, not decorative: the essay reads the whole speech through the audience's psychology of ambition, tracks how the choices cooperate, and closes by identifying the speech's deepest move — exposing a ranked path as a choice.
The Country Doctor's Address · mid-scoring response3/6

In her 1988 commencement speech, Dr. Alma Reyes uses personal anecdotes, statistics, and metaphors to persuade medical school graduates to work in rural areas instead of cities.

Reyes begins with an anecdote about her own life. She was offered a residency at a famous hospital but turned it down to work in a town of nine hundred people. Her professors thought she was wasting her training. This is ethos because she actually lived the life she is recommending, so the graduates will trust her advice more than if she had stayed in a city.

Next, Reyes uses logos by giving statistics. She says there is one doctor for every three hundred people in the cities but only one for every three thousand people in rural counties. This statistic proves that rural areas need doctors much more than cities do. Logical evidence like this is hard to argue with, so it makes her argument stronger.

Reyes is also angry at doctors who choose the city, because she says they only care about prestige and being seen by others. She uses a metaphor that compares prestige to a spotlight and usefulness to a lamp. This metaphor shows the audience that being useful is better than being famous, because a lamp actually helps you see the work.

At the end of the speech, Reyes says the diploma "will not say where to go" and that the graduates have to write that page themselves. This ending makes the audience think about their own future choices instead of just listening to hers.

Overall, Reyes's anecdotes, statistics, and metaphors make her speech persuasive and convince at least some of the graduates to think about practicing rural medicine.

How it scored

1/1A — The thesis is defensible — three choices tied to a purpose — so it earns Row A. But it is the standard device-list template, and it makes no claim about how the speech handles an ambitious audience.
2/4B — Evidence is relevant, but commentary stays generic: 'the graduates will trust her,' 'hard to argue with,' 'makes the audience think.' The essay never explains the irony of 'waste' or why the statistics indict doctors' choices. It also misreads the speech: calling Reyes 'angry at doctors who choose the city' contradicts her explicit concession that 'cities need surgeons,' an overreach that attributes a claim she never makes. That faulty reading keeps the row at 2.
0/1C — No sophistication point. Devices are labeled and treated separately, the audience is generic, and the misread tone shows the essay is not tracking the speech's actual strategy.

Where points die

Summarizing what the writer says instead of analyzing what the writer does. Whole paragraphs restate the passage's argument in different words, and the reader finds no analysis to score. Run every body paragraph through the same loop: name a specific choice, quote it, then explain the effect it has on this audience and how that effect serves the writer's purpose. If a sentence would survive in a plain summary of the passage, it is not analysis.

Device-spotting: labeling ethos, pathos, anaphora, or 'rhetorical questions' as if the label were the analysis. 'This engages the reader' and 'this builds credibility' are the sentences that keep essays at 2 out of 4 on Row B. A named device earns nothing by itself. A writer's passive constructions, for example, are not a style fact to point out — they are evidence for a claim about what the writer wants the audience to believe. Always finish the thought: this choice makes this audience feel or conclude this, which the writer needs because of that.

Overreaching: attributing claims the writer never makes. A writer who exposes how budget rhetoric hides choices is not saying cuts are never necessary; a speaker who praises rural practice is not condemning everyone who works in a city — especially when she concedes the opposite outright. Stay inside what the text actually does. Before writing 'the author argues X,' check that a sentence in the passage commits to X. Concessions are part of the argument; an analysis that ignores them will misstate the writer's position and lose Row B points for faulty reading.

Misreading tone: calling an argumentative passage 'balanced,' 'neutral,' or 'objective,' or flattening a wry, satirical, or ironic voice into 'angry' or 'critical.' Op-eds, public letters, and speeches take positions — that is why they exist. Choose tone words you can defend with quoted language, and notice when a writer concedes ground or jokes: concession and irony are deliberate choices with audience effects, not signs of neutrality.

Treating any biographical detail as an automatic 'ethos appeal.' Writers mention their experience for many reasons; twenty-two years as a librarian or thirty years as a rural doctor is not credibility by default. Explain what the background does in this argument. Marsh converts her tenure into eyewitness authority so her examples count as testimony; Reyes uses her past to reclaim the word 'waste.' Say what position the detail builds for the writer with this audience, not just that it 'makes her credible.'

A thesis that restates the prompt: 'The author uses diction, imagery, and syntax to convey her message.' It names no actual argument, no actual choices, and no effect — and it caps everything the body paragraphs can do. Make the thesis say something a reader could disagree with: what the writer's purpose is, which specific choices serve it, and how. If your three named choices could describe any passage ever written, the thesis is not yet doing its job.

Score your own response

0 / 6

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.