The Librarian's Letter
The following letter was written in March 1970 by Helen Marsh, head librarian of the public library in the fictional mill town of Harlan Falls, Ohio. The town council had proposed cutting the library's budget by ending evening and Saturday hours.
To the members of the Harlan Falls Town Council:
I have been the librarian of this town for twenty-two years. In that time I have learned the names of three generations of readers. I checked out Charlotte's Web to children who now bring me their own children on Saturday mornings. So I ask you to hear me not as a department head defending a budget line, but as a witness testifying to what that line buys.
You have called the library a luxury. I want to examine that word. A luxury is a thing we enjoy but could do without. Last winter, Mr. Kowalski, who lost his job when the mill cut its second shift, sat at our reading table every morning with the classified pages and a borrowed dictionary, teaching himself to write a letter of application. Was that a luxury? The Hendricks girl, who has no encyclopedia at home, has written every school report of her life at our corner table. Was that? The men who come in to read the Cleveland papers because a subscription costs more than they can spare — are they enjoying a luxury, or exercising a right?
The proposal before you would save the town four thousand dollars by closing our doors on evenings and Saturdays. But hours are not trimmings. Evenings and Saturdays are the only hours a working man has. Cut them, and you have not shortened the library. You have closed it to everyone whose labor pays for it, and kept it open for those who need it least.
I know the arguments of necessity. The budget must balance. Cuts must fall somewhere. But a budget is not weather. It does not simply happen to us. It is a list of what we have decided to care about, written in numbers. I ask the council to look at that list and say plainly: we have decided that the reading of our neighbors is what we care about least.
If you make that decision, make it with open eyes. Do not call the library a luxury so that the decision feels easier. The word does not make it true; it only makes it quiet.
Respectfully, Helen Marsh
- (1)Read the passage carefully. Write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Marsh makes to convey her message to the town council. In your response: state a defensible thesis about Marsh's rhetorical choices; support it with specific evidence from the letter; explain how each choice you discuss helps Marsh achieve her purpose with this audience; and show that you understand the rhetorical situation — who is writing, to whom, and under what pressure.