Which of the following correctly explains why ice is less dense than liquid water?
- ALiquid water has more hydrogen bonds per molecule than ice, making liquid denser.
- BIce crystals form a hexagonal hydrogen bond network where molecules are held at fixed distances in a less compact arrangement than in liquid water, creating a lower-density open lattice.Correct
- CIce contains dissolved air bubbles that reduce its density below that of liquid water.
- DWater molecules in ice move faster, taking up more space per molecule.
Why B is right
In ice, each water molecule forms four hydrogen bonds in a rigid hexagonal crystal lattice. This tetrahedral, open arrangement holds molecules farther apart than in liquid water, giving ice a lower density (0.917 g/cm3) than liquid water (1.000 g/cm3). In liquid water, the hydrogen bond network is less ordered, constantly breaking and reforming, allowing molecules to pack slightly more closely on average.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. Ice actually has MORE hydrogen bonds per molecule (4) than liquid water (average ~3.4 at 25°C) because liquid water's dynamic structure allows some bonds to be broken at any instant.
- C
- Incorrect. While ice cubes from a refrigerator may contain some air bubbles, the fundamental density difference between pure ice and pure water is due to crystal structure, not air bubbles.
- D
- Incorrect. In ice, molecules are FIXED in the lattice and do not move freely; thermal motion is less than in liquid water, not more.