Skip to content
AP Chemistry · Properties of Substances and Mixtures

Water anomaly

Water anomaly appears in 3 reviewed AP Chemistry questions and sits in Properties of Substances and Mixtures. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Water anomaly is tested

Example 1Medium
Which of the following correctly explains why ice is less dense than liquid water?
  1. ALiquid water has more hydrogen bonds per molecule than ice, making liquid denser.
  2. BIce crystals form a hexagonal hydrogen bond network where molecules are held at fixed distances in a less compact arrangement than in liquid water, creating a lower-density open lattice.Correct
  3. CIce contains dissolved air bubbles that reduce its density below that of liquid water.
  4. DWater molecules in ice move faster, taking up more space per molecule.

Why B is right

In ice, each water molecule forms four hydrogen bonds in a rigid hexagonal crystal lattice. This tetrahedral, open arrangement holds molecules farther apart than in liquid water, giving ice a lower density (0.917 g/cm3) than liquid water (1.000 g/cm3). In liquid water, the hydrogen bond network is less ordered, constantly breaking and reforming, allowing molecules to pack slightly more closely on average.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect. Ice actually has MORE hydrogen bonds per molecule (4) than liquid water (average ~3.4 at 25°C) because liquid water's dynamic structure allows some bonds to be broken at any instant.
C
Incorrect. While ice cubes from a refrigerator may contain some air bubbles, the fundamental density difference between pure ice and pure water is due to crystal structure, not air bubbles.
D
Incorrect. In ice, molecules are FIXED in the lattice and do not move freely; thermal motion is less than in liquid water, not more.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Properties of Substances and Mixtures.