A researcher studies the phase diagram of water and notes the triple point at 0.006 atm and 0.01°C. What happens if water vapor at 0.004 atm and -5°C is heated at constant pressure until it reaches 100°C?
- AThe water remains as vapor throughout because pressure is insufficient to form liquid water.Correct
- BSince 0.004 atm is below the triple point pressure, the water vapor first deposits to solid ice upon cooling and the ice sublimes directly without forming liquid; upon further heating at 0.004 atm, the ice sublimes directly to vapor again without passing through the liquid phase.
- CThe water vapor first deposits to ice, then the ice melts to water at 0°C, then water boils at 100°C.
- DThe water vapor condenses to liquid water, then the liquid boils to steam at 100°C.
Why A is right
The triple point of water is at 0.006 atm and 0.01C. At any pressure BELOW the triple point pressure, the liquid phase of water is not thermodynamically stable; the substance can only exist as solid or vapor, with a direct solid-vapor (sublimation/deposition) transition. Here the system is held at a constant pressure of 0.004 atm, which is below 0.006 atm. The starting state is water vapor at -5C. Heating at constant pressure moves the state to the right on the phase diagram (toward higher temperature), which is deeper into the vapor region. Therefore the water stays as vapor the entire way to 100C and never forms liquid. Liquid water could only appear if the pressure exceeded the triple point pressure. This is the same reason dry ice (solid CO2) sublimes rather than melting at 1 atm, below CO2's triple point pressure. Choice C is wrong because ice cannot melt to liquid below the triple point, and choice D is wrong because vapor cannot condense to liquid below the triple point. Choice B is wrong because the process is heating, not cooling, so the vapor does not deposit to ice; heated vapor simply remains vapor.
Why the other 2 choices miss
- C
- While deposition (vapor to solid) can occur at low temperatures and below-triple-point pressures, melting to liquid is NOT possible below the triple point pressure. At 0.004 atm, ice sublimes directly; it cannot melt to liquid water.
- D
- Condensation to liquid followed by boiling occurs only at pressures above the triple point (0.006 atm). At 0.004 atm (below triple point), the liquid phase is absent from the phase diagram, so vapor cannot condense to liquid water.