A reaction is nonspontaneous at low temperatures but becomes spontaneous at high temperatures. What are the signs of delta_H and delta_S for this reaction?
- Adelta_H > 0, delta_S > 0Correct
- Bdelta_H < 0, delta_S > 0
- Cdelta_H > 0, delta_S < 0
- Ddelta_H < 0, delta_S < 0
Why A is right
From delta_G = delta_H - T*delta_S: For a reaction that is nonspontaneous at low T (delta_G > 0) but spontaneous at high T (delta_G < 0), both delta_H and delta_S must be positive. At low T, the positive delta_H term dominates, making delta_G positive. At high T, the T*delta_S term (which is subtracted) becomes large enough to make delta_G negative.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect. When delta_H < 0 and delta_S > 0, delta_G is always negative at all temperatures, meaning the reaction is always spontaneous.
- C
- Incorrect. When delta_H > 0 and delta_S < 0, delta_G is always positive at all temperatures, meaning the reaction is never spontaneous.
- D
- Incorrect. When both delta_H and delta_S are negative, the reaction is spontaneous at low temperatures and nonspontaneous at high temperatures, which is the opposite of what is described.