In a thin-layer chromatography (TLC) experiment, compound A travels 4.0 cm and compound B travels 2.0 cm from the baseline (total solvent front distance = 8.0 cm). What are the Rf values for A and B, and which compound has stronger affinity for the stationary phase?
- ARf(A) = 2.0, Rf(B) = 1.0; compound A moves faster and has stronger affinity for the mobile phase.
- BRf(A) = 0.50, Rf(B) = 0.25; compound A has stronger affinity for the stationary phase.
- CRf(A) = 0.50, Rf(B) = 0.25; compound B has stronger affinity for the stationary phase.Correct
- DRf(A) = 0.25, Rf(B) = 0.50; compound A travels farther and has a lower Rf.
Why C is right
Rf = distance traveled by compound / distance traveled by solvent front. Rf(A) = 4.0/8.0 = 0.50. Rf(B) = 2.0/8.0 = 0.25. A higher Rf means stronger affinity for the mobile phase (travels farther). A lower Rf means stronger affinity for the stationary phase (travels less). Compound B (lower Rf = 0.25) has stronger affinity for the stationary phase.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. Rf values are ratios and must be between 0 and 1; values of 2.0 and 1.0 would mean the compound traveled farther than the solvent front, which is impossible.
- B
- Incorrect. The Rf values are correctly calculated (A=0.50, B=0.25), but compound B — not A — has stronger affinity for the stationary phase; B travels less because it is more retained by the stationary phase.
- D
- Incorrect. Rf(A) = 0.25 would require A to travel 2.0 cm, but the problem states A travels 4.0 cm; the values are swapped.