Which of the following correctly describes the photoelectric effect and its implication for the nature of light?
- AElectrons are ejected from a metal surface regardless of frequency as long as the intensity is high enough, showing light carries continuous energy.
- BElectrons are ejected from a metal surface only when light exceeds a threshold frequency, demonstrating that light consists of quantized photons.Correct
- CElectrons are ejected only when the metal is heated to a threshold temperature, demonstrating that light and heat are equivalent.
- DElectrons are ejected from a metal surface when light of sufficient wavelength strikes it, showing light behaves as a wave.
Why B is right
Einstein's explanation of the photoelectric effect showed that light must consist of discrete packets of energy called photons. Each photon has energy E = hf. Only photons with frequency above a threshold value have enough energy to eject an electron. Increasing intensity (number of photons) at low frequency does not eject electrons.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Intensity alone cannot eject electrons if the frequency is below threshold, which directly contradicts the wave model's prediction and supports the particle (photon) model.
- C
- The photoelectric effect depends on light frequency, not the temperature of the metal. Thermionic emission involves heat, not the photoelectric effect.
- D
- This inverts the correct relationship — the photoelectric effect is NOT explained by wave behavior. It is the failure of the wave model to explain threshold frequency that led to the photon concept.