In the context of atomic orbital theory, the 2p and 2s orbitals in an isolated carbon atom are degenerate in hydrogen but not in multi-electron atoms. Which factor lifts the degeneracy of s and p orbitals in multi-electron atoms?
- AThe Pauli exclusion principle, which forces s and p electrons to have different energies to avoid identical quantum states
- BElectron-electron repulsion, which raises the energy of all occupied orbitals in the atom by the same amount
- CRelativistic effects, which cause p electrons to move faster than s electrons near the nucleus
- DShielding and penetration: s electrons penetrate closer to the nucleus and are less shieldedCorrect
Why D is right
In hydrogen (one electron), orbitals with the same principal quantum number n are degenerate. In multi-electron atoms, electrons in inner orbitals shield outer electrons from the full nuclear charge. The key is penetration: s electrons have a nonzero probability of being found close to the nucleus (they penetrate the inner electron cloud), so they experience less shielding and are attracted more strongly by the nucleus. This lowers the energy of s orbitals relative to p orbitals of the same n. Thus, for n=2: E(2s) < E(2p) in multi-electron atoms.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The Pauli exclusion principle states that no two electrons can have the same four quantum numbers. It does not determine the relative energies of orbitals.
- B
- Electron-electron repulsion raises orbital energies, but it does not raise all orbitals equally. Shielding and penetration effects cause differential energy shifts.
- C
- Relativistic effects are important for very heavy atoms (like gold) but are not the primary explanation for 2s/2p energy differences in typical multi-electron atoms like carbon.