A student investigates the solubility of four gases in water at under . Results: (), (), (), (). Which property of the gas BEST predicts its water solubility in this series?
- AThe greater the polarity or polarizability of the gas molecule, the higher its water solubility, due to stronger gas-water interactions.Correct
- BThe higher the molecular weight, the lower the solubility, because heavier gases have more inertia and cannot enter the water.
- CThe larger the gas molecule, the more water molecules it displaces, reducing solubility.
- DAll gases have equal solubility because Henry's Law predicts solubility based on pressure alone.
Why A is right
() has much higher water solubility than , , or . is a polar molecule (linear but with polar bonds that give it a large quadrupole moment) and can react with water to form carbonic acid (), enhancing apparent solubility. More importantly, has a higher polarizability (more electrons, ) compared to (), (), and (). Higher polarizability stronger gas-water (London dipole-induced dipole) interactions higher solubility. The trend also follows polarizability/electron count. This relationship is captured by the Henry's Law constant, which reflects both physical solubility and gas-water interaction strength.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Molecular weight and inertia do not determine solubility. () is heavier than () or (), yet is far more soluble. If weight alone determined solubility, should be the least soluble.
- C
- Molecular volume affecting solubility through water displacement is not a primary determinant. is tiny yet has lower solubility than . The interaction strength (London forces polarity) dominates.
- D
- Henry's Law () states that at a given pressure and temperature, solubility is proportional to partial pressure — but (the Henry's constant) differs for each gas, reflecting their different interaction strengths with water. Henry's Law does not predict equal solubility for all gases.