The effective nuclear charge (Z_eff) experienced by a valence electron in sodium (Z = 11) is approximately +1. Which of the following best accounts for this value?
- AThe 10 core electrons each shield about one unit of charge, lowering the nuclear pull on the valence electron.Correct
- BThe electron-electron repulsion among the 10 core electrons pushes the valence electron to a higher energy level.
- CThe 11 protons are distributed among three energy levels, so each level receives roughly equal nuclear attraction.
- DSodium's single valence electron is in the 3s orbital, which cannot penetrate the inner electron cloud.
Why A is right
Sodium has 11 protons and the electron configuration 1s2 2s2 2p6 3s1. The 10 inner-shell (core) electrons effectively shield the valence electron from the full nuclear charge. Each core electron contributes approximately one unit of shielding, so Z_eff ≈ 11 - 10 = +1.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect. While electron-electron repulsion exists among core electrons, it is the shielding effect (core electrons blocking nuclear attraction) that primarily determines Z_eff, not repulsion pushing the valence electron outward.
- C
- Incorrect. Nuclear charge is not distributed among energy levels. All 11 protons are in the nucleus, and shielding by inner electrons reduces the effective charge felt by outer electrons.
- D
- Incorrect. The 3s orbital actually does penetrate the inner electron cloud to some extent, which is why s electrons experience slightly higher effective nuclear charge than p electrons in the same shell.