Which of the following correctly describes why HI is a stronger acid than HF?
- AIodine is more electronegative than fluorine
- BThe H-I bond is stronger than the H-F bond
- CHI has more lone pairs available for proton donation
- DThe H-I bond is much weaker than the H-F bond, making it easier to breakCorrect
Why D is right
For binary acids in the same group, acid strength increases going down the group because bond strength decreases as the halide gets larger. The H-I bond (297 kJ/mol) is much weaker than the H-F bond (570 kJ/mol). The weaker bond breaks more easily in water, releasing H+ more readily and making HI a stronger acid.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. Fluorine is more electronegative than iodine (4.0 vs 2.7). Electronegativity would predict HF to be stronger, but bond strength is the dominant factor for binary acids in the same group.
- B
- Incorrect. A stronger H-X bond would make the acid weaker because the proton is held more tightly. The H-I bond is actually much weaker than H-F.
- C
- Incorrect. The number of lone pairs on the halide does not determine acid strength. Both F and I have 3 lone pairs. Acid strength of binary acids depends primarily on bond strength.