The graph of f is shown. What is limx→2f(x) if f has a hole at (2,3) and the graph approaches y=3 from both sides?
- AThe limit does not exist
- B2
- C3Correct
- Df(2)
Why C is right
The limit as x→2 depends only on what the function approaches, not the function's value at x=2. Since both the left-hand and right-hand limits approach 3, limx→2f(x)=3, even though there is a hole (f(2) may be undefined or different).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Students incorrectly think a hole means the limit doesn't exist; a hole only affects the function value, not the limit. This distractor comes from stopping at the unsimplified form or using the raw 0/0 result as if it were the answer. The correct limit is found after the algebra is cleaned up.
- B
- Students confuse the x-value with the limit value. This distractor comes from stopping at the unsimplified form or using the raw 0/0 result as if it were the answer. The correct limit is found after the algebra is cleaned up.
- D
- Students confuse the limit with the function value; these are equal only when the function is continuous at that point. This distractor comes from stopping at the unsimplified form or using the raw 0/0 result as if it were the answer. The correct limit is found after the algebra is cleaned up.
The table below gives values of f:
| x | 1.9 | 1.99 | 2.01 | 2.1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| f(x) | 3.61 | 3.9601 | 4.0401 | 4.41 |
Which of the following best approximates limx→2f(x)?
- A3.61
- B4.0Correct
- C4.41
- DThe limit does not exist
Why B is right
As x approaches 2 from both sides, f(x) approaches 4. The values 3.9601 and 4.0401 are closing in on 4 from below and above respectively. So limx→2f(x)≈4. (Indeed, f(x)=x2 gives f(2)=4.). The result follows from simplifying the expression, using continuity, or applying the stated limit law. The raw indeterminate form is only a starting point; the simplified expression determines the answer.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Students use the value farthest to the left rather than the values closest to x=2. This distractor comes from stopping at the unsimplified form or using the raw 0/0 result as if it were the answer. The correct limit is found after the algebra is cleaned up.
- C
- Students use the value farthest to the right. This distractor comes from stopping at the unsimplified form or using the raw 0/0 result as if it were the answer. The correct limit is found after the algebra is cleaned up.
- D
- Students mistakenly think a table can't establish a limit, or that the slight asymmetry signals the limit doesn't exist. This distractor comes from stopping at the unsimplified form or using the raw 0/0 result as if it were the answer. The correct limit is found after the algebra is cleaned up.
The graph of f has a vertical asymptote at x=3. As x→3+, the graph increases without bound. As x→3−, the graph decreases without bound. Which statement correctly describes limx→3f(x)?
- Alimx→3f(x)=∞
- Blimx→3f(x)=−∞
- Climx→3f(x)=0
- Dlimx→3f(x) does not existCorrect
Why D is right
The left-hand limit is −∞ and the right-hand limit is +∞. Since the one-sided limits are not equal, the two-sided limit does not exist. Note: even if both sides went to +∞, we would say the limit is ∞ (DNE in the finite sense), but here the sides disagree entirely.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Students see a vertical asymptote and assume the limit is always +∞, ignoring the left-side behavior. This distractor comes from stopping at the unsimplified form or using the raw 0/0 result as if it were the answer. The correct limit is found after the algebra is cleaned up.
- B
- Students focus only on the left-side behavior. This distractor comes from stopping at the unsimplified form or using the raw 0/0 result as if it were the answer. The correct limit is found after the algebra is cleaned up.
- C
- Students confuse a horizontal asymptote at y=0 with the behavior near the vertical asymptote. This distractor comes from stopping at the unsimplified form or using the raw 0/0 result as if it were the answer. The correct limit is found after the algebra is cleaned up.