In an experiment, a researcher removes all herbivores from a grassland plot. Which of the following is the most likely outcome over several years?
- ACarnivore populations will increase due to reduced competition with herbivores
- BThe total biomass of the ecosystem will decrease because herbivores recycle nutrients
- COne or a few dominant plant species will outcompete others, reducing overall plant diversityCorrect
- DThe diversity of plant species will increase because all plants can grow without herbivory pressure
Why C is right
Without herbivores to selectively consume dominant plant species, competitively superior species can monopolize resources and outcompete subordinate species. Herbivores often promote diversity by keeping dominant species in check, allowing less competitive species to coexist. Their removal typically leads to competitive exclusion and reduced plant diversity.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. Removing herbivores would reduce the food supply for carnivores, likely causing carnivore populations to decrease, not increase.
- B
- Incorrect. Total plant biomass would likely increase without herbivory, not decrease. Herbivores consume plant material, reducing standing biomass.
- D
- Incorrect. Without herbivory, dominant species are free to outcompete others. Herbivory actually promotes diversity by reducing the dominance of competitively superior species.